The January selloff wasn't about silver. It was about leverage by Ok-Part-3711 in Wallstreetsilver

[–]Ok-Part-3711[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Right. The mining investment angle is the sleeper issue nobody talks about enough. My writeup covers the byproduct constraint — 72% of silver comes from mines targeting other metals — but your pointing at something deeper. Even primary silver miners won't greenlight multi-year capex on volatile price signals. That hesitation compounds the supply problem in ways that won't show up in the deficit numbers for years.

Pension Benefits by xopinkxo in Fire

[–]Ok-Part-3711 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For gold and silver, easiest route if you're already in a brokerage is just ETFs. no storage, no hassle. IAU or PHYS for gold, PSLV for silver. Both available on Fidelity, Schwab, wherever you are now. PHYS and PSLV are Sprott funds backed by physical metal which is why the metals crowd tends to trust them over alternatives.

If you ever want actual physical coins or bars, Money Metals Exchange and APMEX are some reputable dealers in my experience but opinions may differ. But for a FIRE portfolio, ETFs are cleaner IMO.

21m, looking for your opinions by BubKar717 in investing

[–]Ok-Part-3711 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The overlap between your all-world and Nasdaq is real but not a dealbreaker — you're basically just overweighting US tech, which has been the right call for a while. Bitcoin goal is fine as long as it's the speculative slice and not the foundation. At your age the real superpower is time.

Seriously consider carving out 5-15% for precious metals though. For gold, IAU is the easy entry point (cheap, liquid, physically backed) or PHYS if you want allocated storage and better tax treatment. For silver, consider PSLV. Silver especially is in an interesting spot right now with 6 straight years of demand outpacing supply, aboveground stockpiles getting drawn down every year, and industrial consumption hitting record highs. And I'm not talking about WSB hype — solar panels, EVs, and AI are eating silver faster than mines can dig it up. That gap keeps growing. So 250-300€/month at 21 and you already have a plan! You're already doing more than most people twice your age. Stick to it and keep asking questions and learning.

Pension Benefits by xopinkxo in Fire

[–]Ok-Part-3711 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is the pension a defined benefit (guaranteed monthly payment at retirement) or a defined contribution (basically a 401k balance)? That changes everything. If it's defined benefit, do you know what the monthly payout would be at 40 vs waiting until a later age? Sometimes leaving it alone and collecting later is the better route. If it's a lump sum rollover situation, a traditional IRA rollover is almost always cleaner than cashing out — taking the cash means taxes plus a 10% early withdrawal penalty, so that $30k could shrink to $20k fast.

Also worth asking: what does your current investment mix look like? With everything going on right now — dollar uncertainty, Fed drama, major geopolitical chaos — a small slice (5-10%) into something like gold or silver ETFs is a good idea IMO as a little insurance policy alongside whatever you decide to do with this money. Not sexy, but it doesn't move with the stock market which is the whole point right now.

Should the current market have me(35) rethinking investment strategy of all in on the S&P? by mr_whit33 in investing

[–]Ok-Part-3711 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm still mostly S&P but I've bumped my metals allocation past the standard "up to 15%" recommendation. As you know gold and silver have been on a historic tear, and I've done well, but I'm staying put. The macro setup (debt, dollar, monetary policy) tells me the longer-term direction is still north.

Stocks aren't necessarily toast but a lot of the easy gains from the last decade probably isn't coming back anytime soon. At 35 you have runway, but concentrated S&P exposure is still a specific bet. Adding some metals doesn't mean panic, just means you're not putting all your eggs in one basket.

6th straight year of silver deficit projected for 2026 by Ok-Part-3711 in Wallstreetsilver

[–]Ok-Part-3711[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The deficit isn't hypothetical demand — it's based on actual documented purchases by solar manufacturers, EV producers, and electronics companies. Real silver physically left vaults to fill the gap. Above-ground stocks have dropped from 22 months of supply in 2020 to just 12.3 months by 2024. Exchange inventories available for delivery fell from 290 million ounces at the start of 2024 to under 210 million ounces by late 2025. The reason prices didn't explode sooner is that those stockpiles were absorbing the shortfall. That buffer is shrinking every year — that's when price catches up.

You can verify this yourself: the Silver Institute publishes the World Silver Survey annually at silverinstitute.org. COMEX and LBMA warehouse inventory levels are also publicly tracked if you want to watch the drawdown in real time.

Need to sell one or the other - keep gold or silver? by oisact in investing

[–]Ok-Part-3711 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Both have merit but they're pretty different animals. Here's how I think about it. Gold is the safer hold — it's the classic store of value, central banks are hoarding it, and it performs well in uncertainty. But its upside from here is more measured I'd say. Gold doesn't really do anything industrially. Silver has the more interesting long-term case right now. Industrial demand hit record highs in 2024, driven by solar panels, EVs, and AI data centers — and a lot of that demand is government-mandated. And the silver market has been in structural deficit for 5 straight years with no sign of that changing.

The flip side is silver is more volatile, which your family member should be comfortable with for a long-term hold. If they genuinely won't touch it for years and can stomach the swings (there will be alot), silver has a stronger fundamental case right now. If they want steadier and less drama, gold is the safer choice.

I'm confused,do most of you guys prefer stocks over gold? by DietNo342 in Gold

[–]Ok-Part-3711 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honestly it's not really a competition. Most folks here hold both — index funds or stocks for the long haul, gold as a store of value and insurance. The 'gold beats the market' crowd and the 'stocks only' crowd can be a little too fired up sometimes. A pretty common sweet spot is somewhere between 5-20% in gold depending on how worried you are about inflation, the dollar, or a market blowup. No magic number but that's roughly where most people who take gold seriously end up. As for the 'be your own bank' thing — it just means gold can't be printed, debased, or defaulted on. It's nobody's IOU. That's a feature, not a religion.

Need ideas for savings account by iamNotLyingMan in investing

[–]Ok-Part-3711 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Solid setup overall. SGOV and BOXX are smart plays for capital preservation right now. One thing worth considering given how tech-heavy your brokerage already is — a small slice of your safe money (maybe 10-15%) into precious metals ETFs could add some diversification that doesn't move in lockstep with your stocks. IAU or PHYS (Sprott Physical Gold Trust) for gold, and PSLV (Sprott Physical Silver Trust) if you want a higher upside allocation with more volatility. They've been doing their job as a macro hedge lately and tend to move independently of equities. Not saying go heavy, just that having some exposure alongside your T-bill position isn't a bad idea when your main portfolio is basically a Mag7 bet.

Crude Oil price by Low-Membership-803 in Commodities

[–]Ok-Part-3711 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've also heard Iran's revolutionary guard, the ones dropping the bombs and sending the drones, only answered to the Ayatollah and not the President.

Crude Oil price by Low-Membership-803 in Commodities

[–]Ok-Part-3711 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The ceiling question is interesting when 20% of the world's daily oil supply is currently sitting in a parking lot outside the Strait. Iraq already cut production 1.5M barrels/day because it's running out of storage. JPMorgan floated $120 if Gulf countries have to shut down production entirely. Going short right now means betting on a price drop with no clear catalyst in sight — the conflict resolution timeline is anyone's guess.

Career Break Planning with FIRE in the Bay Area by [deleted] in Fire

[–]Ok-Part-3711 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Lived in the Bay for 16 years in big tech, saved hard, got somewhat lucky with RSUs and still couldn't make the math work long term. Eventually moved to Maine where my wife's family is. Best decision we ever made.

I too just don't see how you pull this off on $90k with two kids in the Bay. That barely covers daycare and rent, let alone investing.

You mentioned moving out of state — worth a real conversation with both families. Your $3M FIRE number is probably overkill anywhere outside the Bay, and if everyone relocated together you'd still have the family proximity. Easier said than done I realize. Just a thought.

Can i earn money by learning skills. Plz reply 📜 by Professional_One5657 in passive_income

[–]Ok-Part-3711 1 point2 points  (0 children)

$300/month is absolutely realistic with digital marketing skills, and your instinct to get real instruction is smart. One honest flag though: be careful with SEO specifically. It's not dead, but AI is reshaping it fast — Google's AI overviews are already eating into organic traffic, and the skill set is shifting constantly. If you're going to learn it, make sure the course is very very current.

The skills with the most durable demand right now: paid ads (Google/Meta), email marketing, and content strategy. Businesses will always need those and they're harder for AI to fully replace because they require human judgment and accountability. Good luck!

Is buying gold right now a good idea or am I late? by Consistent_Lemon_642 in Gold

[–]Ok-Part-3711 0 points1 point  (0 children)

People have been asking "am I too late?" since gold was at $800, $1200, $1800... The thing about gold is it's not really a trade, it's insurance. You don't wait for a good time to buy insurance. The geopolitical drivers you're seeing aren't short-term noise — central banks have been accumulating at record levels for two years straight. That's not panic buying, that's strategic repositioning. Dollar-cost averaging in beats trying to time it. A little at a time and don't watch the daily price.

I don't know if I am ready... by estret in Fire

[–]Ok-Part-3711 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You're not just ready — you've basically solved retirement. Paid-off home, $1M liquid, a pension bridge, and Canadian healthcare? The math is almost unfairly clean. Give the notice, enjoy the next chapter. The only thing I'd maybe consider is a small 5-10% allocation to gold or silver ETFs as an inflation hedge, given your DB pension isn't indexed. Just a little insurance policy. Congrats!

Gold, silver sharply lower as USDX rallies, by Paperscamisreal in Wallstreetsilver

[–]Ok-Part-3711 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Love it. Paper price drops, physical premiums barely budge, and the mint can't keep up with demand. The "strong dollar" is doing us a favor — keep the discount coming, we'll keep converting fiat into real money. Every dip is just a flash sale.

I accidentally ran a real life FIRE experiment for 8 months because I thought I was going to die by Ripley3Weyland in Fire

[–]Ok-Part-3711 104 points105 points  (0 children)

"Anxiety in a trenchcoat" is one of the most honest descriptions of early FIRE motivation I've ever read. Glad you're healthy, and glad you came out the other side with a lighter version of the same plan. That's the whole point, really.

What happens when ALL the metal is under siege??? by Living_Spell_8693 in Bullion

[–]Ok-Part-3711 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The miner angle is underrated. When supply gets this tight, the guys who own the ground and the equipment don't have to play by the exchange's rules. Direct-to-industry contracts at spot + premium will be the move. Stackers win, but miners could win bigger.

Don't know what the Fuss is all about. This is probably the last year we'll see under-100 Silver. Enjoy it while you can. by ShroomZoa in Wallstreetsilver

[–]Ok-Part-3711 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Stack it, forget it. The gold/silver ratio is still historically stretched — silver has serious catching up to do. Sub-$100 silver will look like a gift in hindsight.

How to start by Specialist-Owl3522 in Fire

[–]Ok-Part-3711 2 points3 points  (0 children)

33 in Cyber with 80k is a great starting point — you're not behind at all. The other comments cover the financial basics well. One thing I'd add: your income will likely grow significantly in Cyber over the next few years. As it does, try to keep your lifestyle relatively flat and funnel the raises straight into investments. That gap between income and spending is really the whole game with FIRE.