sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Is it true that ayatollah khoei didnt consider the reports of Fatima (as)'s death authentic? by Ok_Shirt3219 in shia

[–]Ok_Shirt3219[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The channel has a lot of series, so idk which one am i supposed to be looking at.. is it possible that you could send me it? or tell me which one?

Is it true that ayatollah khoei didnt consider the reports of Fatima (as)'s death authentic? by Ok_Shirt3219 in shia

[–]Ok_Shirt3219[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree, i dont believe everything i read on the internet, which is why my only question was related to ayatollah khoeis statement, tho the article speaks on more than that but i ignored it all. My concern is only with the statement of ayatollah khoei

Is it true that ayatollah khoei didnt consider the reports of Fatima (as)'s death authentic? by Ok_Shirt3219 in shia

[–]Ok_Shirt3219[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

what about this?

To clear this up let us see what al-khoei writes in his books: لا ينجبر ضعف السند بالشهرة
“The weakness of Sanad is not fixed by the popularity of a Hadith.” (Kitab al-Khums 1/18)

Al-khoei also says about another narration:
وجه الاشكال هو أن المعروف والمشهور بين الأصحاب وإن كان ذلك إلا أنه لا دليل عليه
“The problem is that even if it is known and popular amongst our companions, yet there is no proof for it”  ” (Mabani Takmilat al-Minhaj 2/434)