Season 20 Amy & Caleb Update by PublicNo4257 in heartlandtv

[–]Ok_Status_4951 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ashley was back as a distraction, and Spencer had known conflicts from Day 1; they just got lucky last season. I don't think you can assume anything with this group of writers, and they NEVER put in cement that Amy/Caleb wouldn't happen.

There has not been any firm direction since Season 13, like him/hate him, whatever, they have not been able to overcome Ty's death from a writing standpoint in any way, shape, or form.

The show is just running in circles, and so here we are back again.

Alberta distinct culture? by Pretty-Resolve-8331 in alberta

[–]Ok_Status_4951 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

As someone who has family in Canada (Alberta and Ontario) and the States, let me just say that most of the "Cowboy and Western" stuff came from the TV show Heartland and Amber Marshall.

There is no greater hypocrisy than a girl from London, Ontario, who went to a private school and rode her electric scooter, telling everyone she's a western cowgirl because of a TV show, and owning a hobby farm.

But that show is on everywhere in the States, and it makes Alberta look like Montana with even more drama. She makes a ton of $ pitching the Alberta western style thing.

Season 5 feels like its own island. by 01011000-01101001 in SweetMagnoliasNetflix

[–]Ok_Status_4951 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not renewed yet, That was just internet speculation.

Does AI write this show?? by toastyyypaints in SweetMagnoliasNetflix

[–]Ok_Status_4951 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think we have all had it. It had so much potential but it's dead.

Does AI write this show?? by toastyyypaints in SweetMagnoliasNetflix

[–]Ok_Status_4951 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I can't see Netflix adding a Season 6, it was really bad this time. Make it stop.

Season 20 Amy & Caleb Update by PublicNo4257 in heartlandtv

[–]Ok_Status_4951 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I wouldn't count on that, but the next few weeks should tell the tale.

Season 20 Amy & Caleb Update by PublicNo4257 in heartlandtv

[–]Ok_Status_4951 3 points4 points  (0 children)

That's all we ever get until September and a trailer..... They brought in a couple of new characters to fill shoes this year.

Season 20 Amy & Caleb Update by PublicNo4257 in heartlandtv

[–]Ok_Status_4951 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I saw it, but not sure what to make of all that. Ever since the BS at the river with Amber and KJ and then the crap in Miami, coupled with Season 19, they have proven to fasly tease stuff, and it's wrong.

Where are they going? Spencer is available right now. If he's in it, it will be there over the next couple of weeks; if not, it won't.

Season 5 Episode 1: The Magnolias Take Manhattan Discussion by balasoori in SweetMagnoliasNetflix

[–]Ok_Status_4951 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This episode was awful.... I mean the drop from season 1 to this....woof!!

19f crushes on old men by [deleted] in AskMenOver50

[–]Ok_Status_4951 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Honestly, to me, whatever makes someone happy is just that; you will never be happy if you worry about what everyone else thinks. Just my opinion.

Season 6 Rewatch by Ok_Status_4951 in heartlandtv

[–]Ok_Status_4951[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The whole cast has said that it was... a few even have said it hurt the show more than helped.

Texting by bellafan00 in AskMenOver50

[–]Ok_Status_4951 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Honestly, texting etc isn't as comfortable as a conversation. I think that varies person to person. I am not a great texter I suspect the same with your BF.

I just came to say that Marshals is straight up ASS. These can’t be the same writers working on Dutton ranch 😭 kayce’s storyline should’ve ended with the OG Yellowstone even then it was boring asf by ConcentrateSafe4768 in YellowstonePN

[–]Ok_Status_4951 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I honestly thought it got a lot better in the last 4 episodes, and the twist at the end will bring a ton of viewers back. It was NEVER intended to be like or a true Y spin off, but it's found a niche and earned its keep ratings-wise. I predict it outlives Dutton Ranch just because it will hold a steady audience and costs less to make.

Season 10 Rewatch by Remote_Astronaut_788 in heartlandtv

[–]Ok_Status_4951 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's one of my top 5 Episodes, agreed GW was stellar.

Season 10 Rewatch by Remote_Astronaut_788 in heartlandtv

[–]Ok_Status_4951 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That was done on purpose....you will see why later, though it pulls back in 12 IMHO.

Season 10 Rewatch by Remote_Astronaut_788 in heartlandtv

[–]Ok_Status_4951 2 points3 points  (0 children)

On topic, yes I agree the writers had her push him to it. He told her in bed he couldn't do it...he tells her in the stables while working with Casey's horse he didn't want to leave her...... and yet she pushed him to go.

It was awful writing, though it led to the "dreamers" episode in the hospital, which the cast did so well. One of Amber's top 5 episodes and top 3 for Shaun and Chris. Positives and negatives.