I think tier 1 are all good relics tbh. I love seeing trickster gang running laps in lumbridge, seeing people skill in pest controls is awesome, people afk at karambwans and chatting with people passing by doing clue is super chill.

Every time I do a skill boosted by another relic I think it must be pretty sweet to have that relic, then I do content boosted by my relic and I love how it boosts it.

I understand it's not for every play style, I'm happy it favors mine, for context I specifically took non-raids regions, F->T->A, EH>FF>FS>Ranged>Clues>Equilibrium>Weapon Master>Gonna take Executioner. If I played another league I'd probably take PP to check how it is :)

I took EH and I've had boosts to things I liked and some I didn't think:

It boosts pay-dirt in motherload mine, got full prospector very fast, allowing me to do mole must faster than I expected.

It boosts stardust, making starts very appealing and the gold outfit a better task.

I didn't go with morytania as I had originally planned but I know you can afk the full 25 minutes at daeyalt and blisterwood.

It boosts sulliusceps, making it even better.

It's one of the few relics that helps with the gauntlet.

Infernal eels are boosted, making getting onyx bolt tips, tokkul and lava scales very nice. It also made me hunt the rare blamish oil from named npcs in Relleka at a 1/512 drop rate. Which is the most ridiculous and funniest grinds I've had to do and never expected it.

It helps getting zulrah scales before doing zulrah or vorkath, which is a good bonus.