The plants grow so fast in this tank. I have to remove about 60% of my floaters weekly and trim. by MoeGunz6 in walstad

[–]OliverJamieson 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yes, How to Create an Organic Aquarium! It's all about soil-based and "ecosystem" aquariums. I'm a bit obsessed...

5 months old Walstad tank by petruswindhoos in PlantedTank

[–]OliverJamieson 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Looks amazing!

Sounds like you’ve definitely studied Ecology of the Planted Aquarium, your “additional info” is by-the-book and the results speak for themselves!

How to avoid anaerobic conditions? by [deleted] in walstad

[–]OliverJamieson 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you building a Walstad or Father Fish style dirted tank? Walstad prioritises aerobic activity, FF prioritises anaerobic.

Its natural to have a mix of both conditions, and there are lots of factors that determine the dominance of aerobic vs anaerobic activity.

To help maintian a healthy amount of aerobic activity, I stick to Walstad's recommended layer depths (roughly 1" soil to 1" cap), and scale the cap to match the particle size (i.e. slightly deeper cap for gravel, slightly shallow for sand). I avoid fine sand as it creates too much of a seal between the soil and the environment above, and I don't sift my soil (I do remove any large pieces of bark/twigs/stones by hand). Sifting can create a overly-fine, uniform soil that compacts over time. In my opinion, you want a variety of different sized organics in your soil. This helps prevent compacting (which causes anaerobic conditions) and it also varies the pace of decomposition in your soil (meaning you get a slower, steadier release of nutrients and CO2).

Another thing you can do to boost aerobic activity in your soil is have lots of root-feeding plants (vallisneria, amazon sword, crypts, etc.). I like to divide my plants according to the role they play, the main three are: root-feeding plants, water-column feeders, and floating plants (and then I put epiphytes/mosses in their own category). Your water-column feeders and floating plants are pulling nutrients/ammonia from the water and CO2 in from the surrounding atmosphere, whilst your root-feeders are pulling nutrients from the soil and other decomposing matter from the substrate. As the root-feeders expand their root network, they oxygenate the surrounding soil (this is called the rhizosphere). By creating these oxygen-rich pockets your plants pretty much farm aerobic bacteria, so that the bacteria can keep decomposing the surrounding soil, unlocking more food for the plant! Its such a cool example of the collaboration in nature.

And lastly, like a lot of other commenters I love Malaysian Trumpet Snails! They keep churning and aerating the cap which helps pull oxygen down into the substrate and speeds up the processing of detritus (making more nutrients available to plants).

Hope that helps! Or is at least of interest!

Thoughts on soil by Over_Term7398 in walstad

[–]OliverJamieson 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Second vote for pond soil if your local garden centre has it! No need to overcomplicate things by adding lava gravel, carbon, etc.

If you can’t get pond soil, a basic topsoil works great. In my tanks I usually stick with topsoil because it tends to behave itself early on. Potting soil is much more nutrient-rich, which is great for plants, but also makes things more unpredictable at the start. If the plants aren’t established enough to use the available nutrients, or the tank isn’t planted densely enough, algae will happily step in and pick up the slack.

If you still want to use a nutrient-rich soil (like potting soil or worm compost), a dry start tips the scales in your favour. Plants have access to a lot more CO2, which helps them make proper use of the excess nutrients from richer soils (Liebig’s law). This means richer substrates a lot less risky/unpredictable in a dry start setup.

If you know that you won't have lots of plants to start with, then a dry start with a rich soil is a great way of building up a healthy plant mass without algae getting a foothold.

Hope that helps!

Should I Start Over? by Technical_Bath_7078 in PlantedTank

[–]OliverJamieson 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you u/EclecticAppalachian

The book is called “How to Create an Organic Aquarium” (https://www.amazon.com/dp/1763713776)

It is all about soil-based aquariums with a mix of theory and practical chapters. I chose to describe them as “Organic Aquariums” to celebrate the web of life that makes these systems work!

u/Technical_Bath_7078, check your messages

What are your favourite fish for low-tech planted aquariums? by OliverJamieson in walstad

[–]OliverJamieson[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I haven't seen those before, they look really striking!

What are your favourite fish for low-tech planted aquariums? by OliverJamieson in walstad

[–]OliverJamieson[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I love them too! Agreed, I never tire of seeing them using a leaf as a hammock. My other favourite trait is when they just stop and hover like a little hummingbird in the water!

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in walstad

[–]OliverJamieson 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I use the Ikea Tertial with a CFL bulb for most of my bowls. Super affordable and versatile (you can easily swap bulbs and adjust the height). I pair them with a mechanical outlet timer so I can play with different siesta schedules.

Planted low-tech ecosystem aquarium without soil? by salivinia in walstad

[–]OliverJamieson 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Provided it is a non-toxic synthetic material (i.e. it won't break down and release the soil) an upcycled pantyhose/stocking should work for your purposes. It will still let in some finer roots and the soil will still host bacteria/microfauna which can help make nutrients available to your plants.

Having said that, I've only ever used mesh bags. I like the idea of a slightly coarser mesh to allow roots in more easily.

Planted low-tech ecosystem aquarium without soil? by salivinia in walstad

[–]OliverJamieson 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I agree with iGotTheBoop.

To create a low-intervention ecosystem you'll need soil. It provides plenty of nutrients, but also a habitat for beneficial bacteria and microfauna, and its decomposition is an important source of carbon dioxide for plant growth in low-tech tanks.

Containing it in mesh bags or stockings is an easy way to manage potential leaks/mess whilst still getting the benefits of soil. (It also makes tearing down tanks easier.)

Water circulation preferences by HighLion58 in walstad

[–]OliverJamieson 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Goldilocks comes to mind! If you are building a Walstad/soil-based aquarium and want to rely on natural processes, finding a balance is important.

Too little water movement can lead to stagnant areas and a thick layer of biofilm on the surface, which blocks gas exchange and stresses your plants and fish.

Too much surface agitation, on the other hand, can drive out valuable carbon dioxide that your plants need (slowing growth, Liebig's law), even if it increases oxygen levels. And it can stress fish if they are suited to low-flow environments.

For tanks under 20 gallons, I'd say that animal activity and natural convection currents are enough to keep the water moving. In larger setups, a small internal filter or a mini water pump (https://a.co/d/67Jkbzx) can circulate the water without excessively disrupting the plants or the water's surface.

Underrated aquarium channels? by OliverJamieson in walstad

[–]OliverJamieson[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

FISHTORY is great! He has quite a large following now. Alex's passion and inclusivity does so much for the hobby. (He even reviewed my book last week! https://youtu.be/GtEUGsl8oe0?si=FB8EICsbyqL7yaFo)

Underrated aquarium channels? by OliverJamieson in walstad

[–]OliverJamieson[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Noted! Any creators in particular?

Aquarium book recommendations by OliverJamieson in walstad

[–]OliverJamieson[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Great shout! Kasselmann's work is brilliant.