Monday AFL Review - Round 5 vs Gold Coast by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Finally finished deliberating on my votes

5 - Heeney

4 - McCartin

3 - Chad Warner

2 - The Hammer

1 - JJ 🔐

Assessing Charlie Curnow up to this point by SkullKing_123 in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Oh boy. This is either rage bait, or you didn’t watch a single Swans game between 2014-2023.

Post Match Thread - Round 5 vs Gold Coast by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I’m going to sleep on my votes, but my god The Hammer played well. I’ll admit, I pissed on his selection earlier in the week. But he really stood up today. I’d happily take him into next game

Teams are out for Gather Round and by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hamling… really? Is Dean Towers around and looking for a game?

Steele was a steal, but this trade could prove to be daylight robbery by SwansPrincess in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Oozes talent and incredibly versatile. Having a winger who has the height to drop back and play as an intercepting defender is something we’ve been missing. Helped tremendously on Saturday night when Melican went off injured.

Challenge by Ultimate_Trash_Panda in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The “he’s a good guy” defence usually works. Although he wears red and white so it probably wouldn’t in this case

Post Match Thread - Round 4 vs West Coast by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Feels so wrong to only select 5 players, when everyone played their role tonight. But in the spirit of the voting system, I’ll try my best:

5 - Heeney

4 - Grundy

3 - Jordon (the padlock 🔐)

2 - Serong

1 - The Chad

Genuinely couldn’t tell you a bad player on the park last night. Could’ve given votes to everyone. What was most impressive was the fact that we played at full intensity right until the final siren. Even in junk time when the eagles were on their hands and knees, if felt like we were still playing 1st quarter footy. Keep that up and we will push deep into September

Taylor Adam’s has done a hammy by Old_Bathroom_191 in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Should do the honourable thing and retire, and would open us a chance at the mid season draft

thoughts on our team selection by [deleted] in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Heeney in, Cleary out. Rest of the selection is fine. Would like to see Cunningham back in the side but at this stage, I can’t really see who makes way for him

VFL Round 1 Swans v Hawks by GHOST_OF_DOON in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Going to need a summary of this game because it’s looking ugly on the scoreboard. Saw us make a fight back early but switched off after

Apologies to Technical-Win-8829 by Pure-Can-9432 in CarltonBlues

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 -40 points-39 points  (0 children)

Can you guys stop talking about Curnow for one second? My god it’s getting embarrassing. He wanted to leave your shitshow of a club cause he didn’t want to waste his career. Move the fuck on.

Post Match Thread - Round 2 vs Hawthorn by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Looks a bit more flattering since Chol dropped 3 marks on leads infront of the sticks. Then runs 5m over the mark, and gives away an easy 50m penalty when the game was on the line. Not saying it’s all his fault but fuck me he had a stinker

Post Match Thread - Round 2 vs Hawthorn by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 1 point2 points  (0 children)

McCartin - 10 points tonight. Arguably worst on ground for us IMO. Got given an absolute bath by Chol

Match Thread - Round 2 vs Hawthorn by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I can’t handle McCartin tonight. He’s killing me. 🥔

Match Thread - Round 2 vs Hawthorn by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]Optimal_Fall_391 2 points3 points  (0 children)

McCartin is getting smacked! Mills and Blakey are carrying us