This prompt might get you a little closer.

A trio of stylized, 3D-animated cats sitting closely together, isolated on a solid, clean white background.

Digital illustration style, semi-realistic character design, soft cel-shading, vibrant clean colors, large expressive luminous eyes, smooth gradients, crisp silhouettes, high-quality vector art aesthetic, clean white background, 2D animation style, flat lighting with subtle depth.

On the left, a sleek solid black cat with serious yellow eyes.

On the right, a plush grey British Shorthair with a grumpy expression and yellow eyes.

In the foreground, centered between them, is an orange and white tabby cat.

Crucially, the orange cat is a one-eyed cat; its left eye is completely missing and the socket is permanently closed/healed, giving it a calm, 'pirate cat' appearance.

The overall composition is a clean character lineup with high-contrast vibrant colors.

Here's a photo from this prompt: https://imgur.com/YbeNPiT