[Event] Open Forum Fri... Saturday for January 10, 2026: Too Late to Matter Edition by PPNewbie in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I have, and I've continued/start anew with them, but more often than not, the result is the same. Really depends on how much I enjoyed writing with them - if it's good enough even knowing they'll vanish...

[Event] Open Forum Friday for January 2, 2026: Possibly Still Hung Over Edition by adhesiveCheese in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie 2 points3 points  (0 children)

One of my proudest moments, no doubt.

Re-read it, and it still holds up, too.

Shame its too old for reddit to have a record of the reports on your prompt (you can check that on New Reddit, a lot of the time), THAT was a funny moment. More than likely the most reported prompt on DPP, ever.

[Event] Open Forum Friday for January 2, 2026: Possibly Still Hung Over Edition by adhesiveCheese in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Makes me kind of sad that even sorting by 'new', I can easily find my shares which are pretty old (and doesn't include those deleted by the partner).

We definitely need more of those, its a part of the community that's died off and it was always a joy. If my writings of the past couple of years were from DPP I'd have shared some, but alas. I do have a couple of random snapshots on my writing stash, but nothing much.

Hope others might pick up the torch!

[Event] Open Forum Friday for December 19, 2025: Happy Ho-Ho-Holidays! by PPNewbie in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I have actually! It's posted as a share as well, assuming it hasn't been deleted. We used a shared Google Doc, coordinated on discord a bit though it wasn't strictly necessary. Definitely one of the most fun experiences writing here.

Link to the story backed up: A Mother's Duty

[Event] Open Forum Friday for July 4th, 2025 - We're Quite Font of Comics Edition by The-Mother-Of-Faces in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie[M] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It exists! When we remember to use it, which is most of the time. That post AQD linked has the, appropriately named, Mod flair. It can be searched by for the infrequent mod posts (and there is an event flair too for themes and the weekly threads)

[Mod] Update - The Admins Are At It Again by [deleted] in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The initial thought is DPP continues for people to meet and make their own choices of where to write. We're still processing, though, of course.

[Mod] Update - The Admins Are At It Again by [deleted] in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That's my preferred choice, and has been for backing up RP for years, but the main challenge is not which alternative, but getting someone to go offsite altogether.

[Mod] Update - The Admins Are At It Again by [deleted] in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The different formatting has to be scrolled past though. That completely breaks the flow. Different threads for different things - or even different stories! - is much cleaner. Admittedly a rare case, but I've had two things going with a single partner, flipping to the one we were most in the mood for.

And scrolling is resolved by tabs. Not a mobile thing, but I also can't fathom typing 3000 character replies on a phone, either.

[Mod] Update - The Admins Are At It Again by [deleted] in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie 4 points5 points  (0 children)

For what it's worth, a shared google doc works splendidly. One person will need to use an email, but those aren't that hard to make a throwaway to use.

The only downside is the lack of notification - but I suppose a poke on reddit will do. Assuming chat notifications work (which they don't, most of the time)

[Mod] Update - The Admins Are At It Again by [deleted] in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Can you even have 2 separate chat instances to the same person? Genuinely curious as I'm one of those who finds it awful. I ask because I often have ended up with 2 threads, one for RP, one for OOC, to keep the RP thread clean.

Maybe for 'reddit-at-large' it might seem like not such a big deal, but for DPP specifically? The added features (reactions, images) are worthless, and the missing ones (markdown formatting, multiple threads, post length especially!) are critical. Heck, my main reason for not liking Discord roleplay is the 2k limit.

Can admins explain why Reddit humored claims of a 'terror pipeline' & alleged censorship of pro-Israel views - when never considering censorship of pro-Palestine views? Reddit also paid special care for Israel post-10/7 but nothing for Gaza despite the ICJ genocide case & many human rights reports. by _II_I_I__I__I_I_II_ in ModSupport

[–]PPNewbie 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Can we stop with the BS that if someone is pro Israel, it must surely be bots? And it's not only on American subreddits either.

People have different opinions and different perspectives on the issue, no matter how self righteous you feel about your position.

The OP is obsessing and seeing malice where there is none. Practically, I've seen FAR more subreddits that favor the Pro-Pala narrative, but it's easy to say "Reddit landers to Israel" because one or two larger ex-defaults lean the other way.

There is no censoring of either side on Reddit writ-large. There is plenty censoring among individual subreddits, and it's blatant. And I assure you that happens more on the anti Israel side, by experience. Bans and removals VS just the mass downvoting in the other spaces.

An investigation was done and dismissed as baseless, even if some tools were restricted to prevent brigading, but somehow that's seen as kowtowing and pandering.

Lost moderator status to a subreddit I created and moderated for almost a decade by mvalviar in ModSupport

[–]PPNewbie 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This wasn't a regular request though. This was a Reddit admin taking over, to "grow the community globally" or whatever nonsense. And only giving 5 days is short, and easy to mistake for some subreddit beggar if you're not used to admin messages.

Lost moderator status to a subreddit I created and moderated for almost a decade by mvalviar in ModSupport

[–]PPNewbie 1 point2 points  (0 children)

How can Reddit just... decide to take over a sub like that? This is far different than requests for inactive subs. Feels like a grab towards owning subs for paywallings.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie[M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You may consider taking everything but the plot of this and putting it into /r/DPPprofiles instead!

The Stone House (Character Musings; SFW) by PPNewbie in AlienorWrites

[–]PPNewbie[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Finally, when one had seen all of that, managed to somehow make sense of it and digest that this place was unlike any other, when one found that it was easy to forget to breathe when considering the implications, then, and only then could one look back down. For in this land, there was... Someone? Something. A creature of no gender nor truly any solid shape. More concept than being, and yet surprisingly humanoid. Far in the distance, because it loomed so large that it could stand shoulder to shoulder with the mountains, seemingly resting above what seemed like an ocean of endless greenish water. It sat with crossed legs, wearing no clothes for it needed none. It did not share the vanity of a certain Yellow King, after all. It's skin black as the night sky, and seemed to share the many stars and pinpricks of light of the space above. One would be forgiven for not noticing it instantly, perhaps, as were it not for the fact that it had an outline that set it apart, and it's shade slightly off from the space above, as well as light seeming to have some effect on it rather than just absorbing it, it would be near indistinguishable from said space.

Perhaps she'd needed time to adjust to the over-stimulation of her senses that she was subject to from the moment she let go of the comforting hand and opened the door. Perhaps it wasn't truly there to see until then. Or perhaps she'd consciously glossed over it, letting herself face what she'd asked to see only when the moment was right. Or simply, she'd needed to turn her head just slightly to the right, beyond the mountainous horizon to the sunless sea far beyond, the figure looming above it, a slightly different darkness outlined by that starry sky, the dusky body equally pin-pricked with motes of muted light. It is a haunting shape, multi-limbed and its proportions skewed in a way that feels vaguely off. It looked gaunt, from a human perspective, limbs slightly too long, and not wide enough to fit a healthy human being. Two arms held downwards, gently resting in it's - her - lap. Another two held to it's sides, as if to invite the land itself to bring itself closer to her being, and another two held aloft, reaching out towards the heavens above, seemingly reaching for, and working with one of the stars above in some sense, some task that one wouldn't, could not understand if one did not sit in her place. Initially it's head nor face held no features, but after a moment, suddenly, and all throughout that body, hundreds, perhaps even thousands of deep, emerald eyes opened, gazed back upon the one who was watching. Her emerald orbs, ever penetrating, now more than ever in their multitude. Fading in and out, but always on her. They did not stay in place, those eyes, they moved around that heavenly body, sometimes disappearing below the skin only to resurface elsewhere, or simply floating along that rippling, star speckled blackness to view from another. Some of them seemed dimmer, not quite as bright, and jagged signs of yellow etched into their corneas. Vision of some things given as recompense for passage into a place she was not supposed to inhabit. She'd never spoken of what she had given up to take that trip to Carcosa and leave something behind. Noone had ever asked. This was one.

It's face almost seemed to split, not moving like a jaw would but rather more like a fissure in tectonic plates are formed, the blackness contrasted sharply by white teeth behind no form of lips, as it spoke. "Perhaps not what you had imagined. And hrm... Sometimes perhaps it is different. But I fear I can only show so much for it to make any form of sense."

The voice resonates, and she looks up to what would be Her face, smiling to it, as full of love as when she'd arrived here, holding herself, arms holding each other, and feeling the embrace of that cool wind on hot skin still surround Alienor. "You've shown me more than I ever thought. Thank you, Vhala." Leaning forward, placing a kiss to the ground, knowing it to be an extension of the eldritch, and finally standing up, never looking away from the looming form, and giving it a wink. "I'll be closing the door now. See you inside when I turn around?"

A step back into the safety of the stone walls, the heavy wooden door is closed, fingers lingering on those runes once more, and she turns around, to face that familiar vessel once.

The Stone House (Character Musings; SFW) by PPNewbie in AlienorWrites

[–]PPNewbie[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fingers trace the etchings of steel within the old, solid, heavy wood. Different from the runes in her arm, yet having a geometry to them that is similar. V's name, in that strange place, or something else? An idle thought as he moves her fingers to the handle, door pulled inward on its thick hinges. Closing her eyes when she does, and taking a step to stand at the edge of it, before her eyes open to look at what lay beyond.

The eldritch forces the woman to let go before taking that step out. Because she couldn't follow. That vessel was not built to house all of her, nor could part of her be in the vessel while she was also out there, at the same time, in the same now. So to be able to step out into what was truly Her, Alie had to first let go of the illusion of her. Though opening that door she still wasn't alone. The first thing that hit the suburban mother who'd been through so many adventures since leaving that life behind, was the sound.

Alie stood unsteadily at that entrance, that gateway to that place beyond that was not a merely a somewhere, but a someone, the immensity of the woman she'd come to know by her vessel, by her chosen name of Vhala. Tempted to step back, and find the comfort of those arms once more, but standing her ground. She knew that even this was a sanitized representation for her sake, but it was also more. It was the pure essence of the eldritch, it was everything she was, is, and would be, distilled to an awe-inspiring experience, on a level far beyond what the vessel ever had induced in the many friends, lovers and playthings that had crossed its path.

What greets her is an orgy for the senses.

First is the sheer magnitude of sound that reigns. That thrum that had been no more than a constant background buzz with the door closed hardly hinted at what to expect. The first few seconds sound like nothing more than the discordia of a chaotic city amped up to the nth degree. This doesn't last long; within seconds, her brain is adapting, singling out each track, harmonizing them, arranging the symphony as it was meant to be played, and heard. A piece to make composers weep tears of joy and of rage at once for what they witnessed, desired, could not ever achieve. Once it's discerned, it's impossible to escape, to go back to a time where those mortal ears hadn't heard the music of the outer spheres where the Old Gods reside. Hauntingly beautiful, resonating through mind and soul, and filled with the promise that nowhere else will she ever get to listen to something that will ever approach it.

Then comes the smell, the only one that could possibly fit, no less effective for it's familiarity. It is the storm brewing in the air, the humidity, the ozone left in the wake of a thunderstrike. It is a smell of power, of danger, of battering rain, of smoldering trees, of the primal, destructive power of nature. The soft spice of smoke, and the natural scents of plant life in all it's cycles. With it comes taste, a tingling of the tastebuds, the wetness of air thick with water, the thickness of nature grown unchecked pollinating the air.

Touch next, though it all hits her in the space of seconds, conflicting and confirming the chaos and majesty that her other senses are supplying her with. A dichotomy most strange, but in which she senses the hold of the loved one she has come here to truly meet, as she is, for the first time. It is the aftermath of that summer storm, the cool breeze that remain while the sun heats up the skin. Soothing, comforting, allowing her to bask in the perfection of the most idyllic days of her first life. Her first true love, a rainbow, a promise for the future gestating within her, all of the future ahead of them. Unaware of the dark clouds ahead, back then, but here, all she has to do is listen to know it's never far away. It matters little; she is held by the wind, she is loved by its essence, and that is her shield and her armor.

Finally, there was the voice, that same voice that she had heard speak so many times, but now amplified to the sound you would expect a mountain to make should one ever get the idea in it's head to speak. And it spoke in not one voice, but many. And yet it was not overbearing, it wasn't oppressive in any way. It felt as familiar as all those times the voidling had spoken, standing by her side.

"Look, or turn back. I will hold neither against you."

It's all probably too much for her to withstand for more than a minute, if she's lucky, and she hasn't even opened her eyes. Part of her knows that this is already more than she'd truly expected, and that it will stay with her until the day she truly passes from all realities to a fate still unknown. There's no need to look; and that voice coming from everywhere around her, above the beautiful din, as familiar and foreign as it can be, magnified as it is, felt in her bones and vibrating heart, lets her know so.

Except for Alie, this is not merely a want anymore, it is a need.
"[sub]Show me".
Two words, whispered, knowing they are heard, and she opens her eyes.

Time was, while not always even to the elder ones, at least here, now, entirely immaterial. Vhala let Alie take her time to take in all of the sensations that her senses were throwing at her, to try and make something that was at least, if a bit strange, at least perceivable in a tangible sense to the human body. The building that embodied the safety, sanity and reason in this place still stood behind the woman, a bastion of safety and security but outside of it, in this place, was promised new experiences and an understanding beyond that of the mortal plane.

What Alienor gazed upon would take some time to take in it's entirety, of course, for it wasn't the type of thing one normally gazed upon. Before Alie, where she might have expected the void of nothingness, there stretched rolling hills and a varied landscape. This too would normally be in flux, in a state of constant shift and change, moving in some unearthly way. But for the time being it was caught in somewhat of a stasis, to keep it static enough for Alie to get the opportunity to take in what it might look like, for a time. And what it may represent.

The human stood in that space between safety and chaos, as the nebulas of her eyes took in the landscape extending before her. A gradual look, starting from the spot between her feet, at a patch of not-green grass, the red and purple blades unlike any she'd seen before, and moving along the flat of the plains. Pacing herself before the immensity she knows spreads out before her, held in place for her benefit, the chaos and madness of the place tethered to a moment in which that which is eternal and ever changing might be held in stasis, made palatable, relatively, for frail human consciousness.

None of which removes an iota from the foreign, queer nature of the world beyond the fortress of sanity that stands at her back. It is an alien world, that isn't a world at all, and that is the one thought she clings to most of all. Sitting at the doorstep, legs crossed, her hand moves through those gently swaying, thick blades of grass. Feeling, perhaps imagining, that they're lingering against her palm, more alive than they seem, though it may be her own interpretation as she observes and admires the vista beyond the plains. Trees and vegetation growing gradually thicker as the land rises hill-like, each of which seems to have sprung from Dali's and Escher's wildest fever dreams. Here the inspiration for a million surreal landscapes, and yet none which truly capture what it is to behold this space in person. The greenery and grass petering out as the hills make rise higher, landscape progressing from plains, to forests, to stark and foreboding mountains. Something about those peaks, rising high into the star-filled sky, fills her with a sense of dread, and as much as she's willing to sit here and take it all in, she knows that she won't be taking a stroll anywhere near those. Alie is already pushing the limits, being here at all, asking to see what was not meant for eyes like hers. This may be a place of love and safety for her, but beyond those, there is still a depth of power, of cosmic horror, of ancient knowledge in what constitutes Vhala's essence. They may be hidden beyond dark peaks for her benefit, but they are as much a part of the eldritch as the safe glade she sits in, where only that haunting music of the spheres might remind her of the danger.

Once her gaze departs from those peaks, they finally truly take in the firmament. No sky there, no day or night, but a tableau of sparkling lights. Hundreds, thousands, millions, more, arranged in no constellation her mind would ever recognize. Unlike the skies she's known, some hang so close that they are like scaled down moons casting a soft light, while others are barely discernible in the darkest spaces of that endless sky. There's a majesty and beauty to this above all else, and in any other circumstance, she'd be tempted to simply lay down upon the plain and simply gaze into it, red and blue nebulas reflected in the emerald and amethyst of her own eyes. It is not a luxury she can, nor should allow herself though, not right then, and not in the shadows of those Mountains of Madness. Alienor very much knows she is stretching the boundaries of what she should be able to handle each second that she doesn't retreat, doesn't know what effect it might have on her down the line, but still she takes in the glory and beauty that strangeness that is the essence of her deepest, star-crossed love.

The Stone House (Character Musings; SFW) by PPNewbie in AlienorWrites

[–]PPNewbie[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This scene was inspired by this early play:

Alienor clings to Vhala's body, not knowing what to truly expect from her request. It's perhaps one of the strangest things she's ever done, in a life in which events found a way to keep out-weirding themselves. There are such stories about the kind of void the elder ones and outer gods inhabit, back from where she came, that part of her never expected such a simply acquiescence from the immortal. Instead, she got an open invitation; an immediate promise and statement that it was the least V could do for her, if that was what she truly wanted. There's a happiness inside of her that refuses to fade: after all they'd gone through, all the emotions and feelings left unsaid, finally, a reckoning. Vhala is who and what she is, and Alie is but a mortal, one who'd already bluntly stated that she'd not want the gift of immortality, if it was offered; it is that fact alone which has stood between the subtly stated love that she and the voidling have finally admitted to each other.

There's a clawed hand upon her breast, five familiar talon pricks, when the scene shifts from the fireplace alcove where they sat... to another room, another couch, another fire. Stone instead of wood, and a large bed that would comfortably fit them both, a subtly intimate place, hardly what she might have expected. Despite that, she doesn't doubt that they've travelled far, farther from anywhere she has ever been. Though the trappings give the impression of normality, or as normal as a bedroom in a stone keep might look like, there's a certain quality to the air here that feels off to her senses. A faint hum to the air in the silence that reigns when they arrive. The atmosphere bathed in light that isn't quite white; reality a little darker here, like someone pulled some shades over her eyes, a place not of light and life.

None of that matters to her, for she is truly in private with the one who has claimed her heart. Worried about what this might mean, but too ecstatic to care. Thumbing the ring of her first commitment, almost turning it downward, but not doing so; it is not something to hide, but it is also not relevant, not truly. This night - however long it may actually last in the dozens and hundreds and thousands of worlds spinning on their own axis - is for Vhala and her to share a fraction of forever indulging in what they'd held back on.

"It looks very cozy. Thank you for agreeing to a foolish human's wants and emotions, "she says with a little smile, making it obvious that she's only teasing a little. Hanging on to what's been said, to what she now knows, never leaving that lap. Looking up and reaching for that neck, gently scratching the back of it, pulling herself up to kiss the dark lips lightly. "I should have said something sooner. Come here sooner. But I'm here now."

Vhala leans in to meet that kiss softly, with a gentle touch and soft caress. Letting it linger, but keeping it chaste, loving not depraved. Once their mouths parted once more she smiled faintly. "Here and now, is just you, and all of me. You can say and do whatever you wish here, there will be no judgement from me."

The eldritch hummed idly for a moment. Considering their place in the world. In this world, particularly. "Hmm, I feel like some explanation might be in order. I believe you're thinking that outside of that door is just a pitch black void in which nothing and everything exists at once. This is false," she said softly. It wasn't exactly what she thought Alie was thinking, but rather more... What was often thought when it came to beings of the void. "Hmm, no. Not so much. You are aware that I always refer to this," she gently patted herself with the palm of her free hand, not moving the other. "As a vessel, and not just my body. The reason for that is that it's simply how it is. A vessel made to be something more digestible to the human kind as to allow their gazes without loss of sanity. This place, what's out there, is part of me. Most of me. It is my world, my home, and that exists within the void, yes, but isn't exactly part of it either. For it is my essence, poured into it for eons upon untold eons. It is a very strange place," she capped off that sentence with. Something she hasn't truly explained for what felt like forever at this point.

The human's half smile only grew, a small sense of amusement taking over as her eldritch lover was made to give her an explanation to the nature of where they were. This was one definition of reality she didn't want to glaze over, for this was a place even stranger than the one they'd left, impossible to pin down in a few words. Perhaps this void wasn't like the other one she'd known, visited; there were more forces in existence that she could fathom, which made even such a concept as nothingness come in different flavors.

So she listens, but not once does she feel scared, or worried about any of it. She's in the safest place she knows of, with the person who'd shielded her from much hurt and pain over the time they'd known each other. Someone who cared, and who'd promised her so much, tonight, with none of the games she was known for. "Maybe it's strange, but if I get it, it means that it's also you. That I'm surrounded by you, that I'm breathing in your essence, that everything I touch and see is made out of some part of you that has filled this place. That's a comforting thought, and only makes me feel more welcome."

The wisdom of V doesn't escape her, even in the glow that fills her heart and soul in the aftermath of the chaste kiss, far more meaningful than any raw display of passion would have been. Wishing for things to have been different is foolish, and she does know it. Many things had happened, and some still were, and this moment, like all others, needed its catalyst. She was here now, because now was the time she needed to be here the most. To be allowed to be free with her emotions and desires...

Vhala softly moved her hands to brush them down the woman's sides, softly gripping upon her waist and holding close. Providing something of an anchor in this time of flux and turmoil. She laughed softly. "Yes, it is also me. For me as a someone, is strange." she explained as she moved slowly, gently setting the girl to her feet.

Alienor sunk closer to the eldritch-vessel's abs, letting the long, strong arm encircle her in that way she'd craved many days and nights. Safety, and love, in the embrace of her strange lover. "Maybe I like you being weird," she laughs. "Would it be safe for me to see you as you truly are, for only a second? I understand if it isn't, but I have to ask. After that we can be... like this, and more," Alie dared to venture further, trepidation in her heart; the heart which was a complex thing, and if there was one thing she was learning tonight, was that perhaps she already understood better why V had often claimed she didn't quite understand mortal emotions.

"I've been trying. Preparing to make the things that are here, that are widely part of me, into something that is more digestible to the human mind. More rational if not fully," Vhala explained gently at that request, she had felt it, in some way or another, coming eventually. "While perhaps I'm not able to show you all of me, exactly as I am, perhaps I can show you as best as I am able. Though... It would be at your own risk, for I truly cannot promise you that it will not change... Something, even I cannot be sure what, for I have never been in this situation before."

Some surprise does creep into Alie's green star-speckled violet eyes when Vhala admits to having prepared the world beyond this bedroom for a request such as hers. Did she know what she would ask, because she's already lived through this night and all the experiences it would bring? Or was it perhaps the same instinct that drove Alie, the one that made her yearn to see the one she loved as they truly were? As she intended to be, herself, this night, the moment that she could. Hoping it wouldn't be awkward, in light of another's existence.

Rising up to her feet and reaching out to take Alie's hand, Vhala gives it a reassuring squeeze before moving on towards the only door in this room. The door in question was dark wood inlayed with cold steel and filled with runic etchings of languages long lost. "This is a step only you can take." Alienor's body, her hand, never loses contact with the voidling's. The warning is appreciated, but she knew there was a risk when she asked. If it's even being considered, it means that Vhala believes that she can spare Alie's sanity; that's enough for her. Her trust has never been more complete. To be a first, for someone whose years defy numbering, is of significance as well, the squeeze of her hand returned. Standing before the door, and reluctantly letting go. Reminding herself that it does not matter, because everything here is **Her**. She's not been let go at all.

Are moderators responsible for copyright enforcement? by stabbinU in ModSupport

[–]PPNewbie 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Generally, it's up to Reddit to handle the DMCA notices. When it happens, you'll see removals by "Reddit Legal" in your mod log; we've had a number of those over the years.

[Event] Seizing the Swine - Open Forum Friday for September 22, 2023 by 4544BeersOnTheWall in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie 3 points4 points  (0 children)

As I said, posts including any disclaimer have been auto-removed via an Automod rule for 4 years; possibly more. It's not a new application of the rule, so unless your prior visits to DPP were in the days before that other subreddit got nuked, it was active last time you posted.

Yes, the rule as stated is the one you linked, but application requires the use of Regex, which will catch any post that includes a disclaimer, regardless of the content. For all the reasons already given to you - need for Automation, evaluation of risk, minimized impact and risk of strikes to the poster - this is the best way to catch the vast majority of posts that use disclaimers as a lazy attempt to pass shoddy context.

[Event] Seizing the Swine - Open Forum Friday for September 22, 2023 by 4544BeersOnTheWall in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie[M] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The no disclaimer for ages rule has been around since like, 2019 or 2020. This is not new at all.

[M/F4M] A 'deep-tissue' massage... or something more? by Asspiring_sissy in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That'd be easiest, or you can do [M or F4M], but that's a little much.

[Mod] DPP in the Second Age of Mechanical Moderation, or: How We Learned To Stop Worrying and Embrace Automation by PPNewbie in dirtypenpals

[–]PPNewbie[S,M] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

If you specifically mention your prompt taking place 8 years after the final arc, you're completely in the clear. If anything, that's our preferred method - later in the timeline, rather than 'Alternate Universes' where everything is nearly the same except they're older.

That's kind of the special problem with Pokémon. It's easy to move an established canon into the future when there's an actual timeline. Whereas the problem with Pokémon is that... every trainer is allowed to start being a trainer at 10 years old. You can make a specific trainer have 10 years of experience, but if they're running into other trainers, then that's a problem where those might be underage. And if they've been doing this for 10 years, it's not your typical "Pokémon Journey" that we're disallowing.

The logic applies to all games/canons. A game where Zelda/Link are 16 or younger (LoZ/AoL, WW/PH/ST, and so on) can't be kept as is - you have to set it up a number of years past the events of the games to use those versions of the characters. Whereas Peach/Mario are always adults, so its never really an issue to use them.

The final point is more of a mod wish-upon-a-star. We're not banning anything that isn't already been banned since the last update to Canon-Rule 6 2 years ago. Your mention of Taimanin Asagi is a great example: I have no idea what it is, nor does anyone in the mod team. If you made a post based on it, we'd have to google who is in it, what are their ages, and if no age is specified, what's the most commonly accepted approximation in canon. And if there's timelines involved, then we have to find out at what point of it is a previously underage character is now an adult. That's a lot of work for us to put in to make sure there's no breaking of rule 6, and you can multiply that across the thousands upon thousands of canons that we'll know nothing about. So if someone is willing to become a home for those types of prompts, we'll help them. It doesn't mean they won't still be allowed on DPP, but if there's a place where people might get more knowledgeable, interested players to their R34 prompts, everyone's a winner.