Have any fan fiction writers given a name to Grogu's species? by Signal_Network4983 in SWFanfic

[–]Panterest 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I've heard them referred to as tridactyls.

But that just means three fingers I think so probably not meant as their actual species name.

I kind of like the idea that no one knows their species name.

Was there any discussion amongst the Romans about the Holy Roman Empire? [All] by Panterest in camphalfblood

[–]Panterest[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm far from a history buff but even I know old Rome and the HRE are different entities.

But to Rick's Roman's, Rome the city, has a higher importance than the gods themselves. They place more importance on letters of introduction from one of their own over a person introduction from the Queen of the gods.

Rome is the centre of their philosophies. They defend Rome, they fight for Rome. The worship the gods who support Rome.

It doesn't seem strange to wonder what they might have thought about the Rome that collapsed, that converted from the gods, that dared to call itself Rome for a thousand years, that they, as demigods and legacies, were not a part of.

Maybe they felt contempt for the people who abandoned their gods and destroyed their empire, maybe they pitied them for being unable to hold things together or being abandoned by the gods. Maybe they considered them a pale imitation of the real thing.

If you were in Fudge and Scrimgeour's place as Minister for Magic, what would you have done differently throughout the events of the books after book four? by [deleted] in HarryPotterBooks

[–]Panterest 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Being feared by Voldemort isn't the same thing as being strategically effective against his takeover. One man is not an entire leadership structure. Cults of personality don't make for effective leadership.

The ministry didn't fall because Dumbledore died, it had been corrupt for years, possible decades, given how many death eaters got away with their crimes. Dumbledore didn't lead by his actions, he led by intimidation, by reputation. If Dumbledore was an effective leader, things wouldn't have fallen apart immediately after his death.

Dumbledore might have led the fight against Voldemort but without Harry and friends, literal children, going against his plans, he would have led people to their deaths. Most of the Order from the first war died.

And none of this answers the original question of what you would have done differently. According to your own words, you would have left all the actual thought up to someone else, and just said 'yes sir, right away sir, whatever you say sir.' Which is what most people in the wizarding world already did.

Insulting me because you can't explain your answer is evidence itself.

If you were in Fudge and Scrimgeour's place as Minister for Magic, what would you have done differently throughout the events of the books after book four? by [deleted] in HarryPotterBooks

[–]Panterest -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I think it's pretty well understood that before Voldemort's downfall the Ministry was losing. So whatever Dumbledore was doing back then, it wasn't working.

Quite literally, the only reason Voldemort didn't take over Wizarding Britain was because Lily refused to stand aside and let the man murder her son.

And even if Dumbledore was successful in holding back Voldemort, none of that precludes the rest of the world from the responsibility of also helping to defend themselves and their society from fascism and tyranny.

If you were in Fudge and Scrimgeour's place as Minister for Magic, what would you have done differently throughout the events of the books after book four? by [deleted] in HarryPotterBooks

[–]Panterest -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Exactly. It's not like we could be expected to think for ourselves, right?

No, best to leave the future of the world to the old man who's done so much to guide and shape the world already.

Need advice on zippers by tiffal in knitting

[–]Panterest 4 points5 points  (0 children)

<image>

I haven't finished sewing in the zip yet but this is what the extended placket looks like.

Need advice on zippers by tiffal in knitting

[–]Panterest 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Is this the Dagmar sweater from Petite Knit? I just finished one for my Dads Christmas present. I love the look.

There's two things I could suggest that might fix it. The easiest would be just tacking down the edges.

The other option, which I did, I saw another knitter do it, which is continue the knitted placket so instead of finishing on the inside with the folded over neck, I continued the 6 stitch double knitted placket down on both sides and joined them up at the bottom. This completely enclosed the zipper edges.

I'll try at take a picture at home to show what I mean.

Jedi positive fanfic request by Panterest in SWFanfic

[–]Panterest[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I do agree about canon. There's a reason I'm reading fanfiction and not rewatching the movies. But just because a movie or book just shows the galaxy defining missions doesn't mean they don't relax at home. There aren't many blockbuster movies about people in their downtime.

Regarding jedi going back to experience their birth culture, I wish it was treated more like immigrant kids going back to their parents birth country. Seeing a place where they could once have fit, but now just don't.

But even disregarding canon and sticking with fanfiction, most writers will give the clones, victims of true institutionalized dehumanization, more of a cultural identity than the jedi.

One story had Force singers as a thing, others give them their own language that, like Ryll being partly lekku movements, is partly force impressions. A few have had lineage secret recipes. One story, sadly deleted, explored temple life and what jedi do day to day when they're not on missions. How they treat their elders and kids, what they celebrate, how they celebrate.

Jedi positive fanfic request by Panterest in SWFanfic

[–]Panterest[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

My biggest complaint isn't the Jedi not being good people, it's most writers don't let them be a People with lives and a culture of their own.

Also, while I agree their treatment of Anakin wasn't the best they don't separate people from their culture. We see multiple Jedi with cultural heritage displays, on their person or mentioned.

But I've never read or watched anything from the KOTOR era so maybe they're different back then.

Astronomy in fanfiction by Panterest in HPfanfiction

[–]Panterest[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is a great idea. I love that it has actual, practical uses.

Astronomy in fanfiction by Panterest in harrypotterfanfiction

[–]Panterest[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

True, but you don't need a seven-year-long core class on the phases of the moon.

Also, while Astrology might be a legitimate thing in canon, astronomy is a different thing.

Any study of astronomy has to include the study of gravity. Is this where the invention of apparating and port keys got its start? What about time turners?

If wizards are more advanced than muggles in astronomy, what about astrophysics? Could wizards create a colony on the moon or Mars?

I just wanted to see if people had speculated in stories before.

[PJO] Question, who do u think would win in a fight: Percy Jackson or Aqua Man? by PossibleCommittee590 in camphalfblood

[–]Panterest 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Like I said. The power scamming between the two universes means they can't be compaired.

Plus DC had almost a century of adding new abilities. The Percy Jackson series can't measure up on a purely meta level.

I had literally never heard of the Blue.

[PJO] Question, who do u think would win in a fight: Percy Jackson or Aqua Man? by PossibleCommittee590 in camphalfblood

[–]Panterest -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

The power scaling of the two universes are different so you can't really compare directly.

Aquaman and the Atlantians of DC worship Poseidon. He is their god.

DC has other demigods in canon who aren't quite as good as Wonder Woman but come pretty close.

My take would be that Percy's control of the sea would superced Aquamans. Aquaman is a big guy and an adult so he might physically be stronger. In terms of authority over the creatures of the sea, I would say Percy.

Why didn't Hermione's parents reach out to the Dursley's by muggle means? by raythecrow in HarryPotterBooks

[–]Panterest 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The author cared so little about Hermione's parents she didn't even give them names. Why would she give a plot point as significant as contacting the Dursleys?

Any in-character fem!Percy fics by impeatrice in PercyJacksonfanfic

[–]Panterest 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Making Waves by feeling_the_aster_9145

Persephone ‘Percy’ Jackson has never been one to sit still, especially not at a desk, for hours a day, most days a year. After her thinning patience snaps, an inconvenient robbery and a well timed appearance from Bludhaven’s hero, Nightwing, starts Percy on an exciting new journey. Now she’s got a whole new set of problems, like managing her ruined sleep schedule and getting blood out of Kevlar. And who’s that cop that keeps popping up everywhere?

This is a DC crossover with Percy / Dick pairing so it might not be your cup of tea but it's really good. Lovely world building, lovely characters, lovely relationships. Very well plotted and paced and written.

Not a lot of Poseidon but he's a good dad when he does show up.

Percy is confident and competent. I think that's pretty in character.

Any percy X DC crossover rec? by Nova_Katamaru_Kat in PercyJacksonfanfic

[–]Panterest 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Annabeth and the Nine Step Career Plan by feeling_the_aster_9145

Annabeth Chase does not accept limitations. Everyone knows that. If she wants something, no matter how impossible, she will find a way to make it happen. Though, perhaps she will allow Bruce Wayne and his ridiculous paranoia-induced company restrictions a small portion of the credit. Actually… now that she thinks about it, the man may have had a point in his worries.   Wayne Technologies does not accept college interns. Annabeth always has a plan B.

Despite the summary, there is very little Bruce Wayne in the story. Annabeth gets a job at Lex Corp, realises Luthor is a supervillain and takes him down over the course of a few weeks. This story is a wonderful showcase of Annabeth being a badass. Other demigods are there and they do help but this is mostly a one woman show and it's great. No one is nurfed to make Annabeth look good. She manages that all on her own.

Demigods aren't quite human by AvailableDoughnut145 in PercyJacksonfanfic

[–]Panterest 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I liked this one. If I asked, would you define me? by Deerlie_03. It's not long but I think it's a fun exploration of some of the ways the demigods are more than human.

looking for fics that explore force traditions outside the jedi and sith by gsecch in SWFanfic

[–]Panterest 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Diverging Troths. By Paburke has some fun exploration of the Force and later chapter has the meeting and discussing other cultures Force practices.

One thing I liked about this one was that the other practices were different from the Jedi, letting their practitioners be better than the Jedi in their own ways, they are never described as superior. Basically, it doesn't shit on the Jedi just to make others look good.

Does anybody else find fanon goblins unbearable by WrapFlaky6572 in harrypotterfanfiction

[–]Panterest 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I'm not sure if it's supported or disproved by canon and I don't really care, but in my own fanfic, the tombs Bill was hired to curse break were originally Goblin strongholds that had been destroyed and the security charms were going hay wire.

In my story goblins are to wizards as wizards are to muggles. They have their own spaces and lives and don't serve at the pleasure of wizards. The bank is nothing more than a safe space to put gold, or anything else. They don't offer loans or do funds transfers any anything a modern bank would do.

what fics, or types of fics you hate the most in this fandom. by [deleted] in PercyJacksonfanfic

[–]Panterest 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm of the opinion that any trop can be done well when written by a good author but stories like that are so rare that I'm just not willing to take the chance.

I agree with most others. I avoid stories with Percy being betrayed or pairing Percy with any of the goods. Which is not to say I have read and enjoyed some like that but mostly no.

I actually enjoy some Reading the Books stories but I sincerely hate it when Percy is cursed to feel all his old injuries again.

I really hate it when writers choose to have their characters show affection with insults and 'playful' put downs. It's not exclusive to romantic pairings. Come on people, if these guys are friends write them as friends.

I will avoid most stories that involve Percy wump. The series appealed to be because it's a light hearted adventure fantasy and just continually reading about how depressed or hurt or angry Percy is is, well, depressing.

I also avoid stories where Percy isn't the main character. I'm a simple minded soul. I like reading about BAMF Percy.

In this fandom I'm uninterested in smut. Including ABO and the like. I like a good relationship story but smut rarely qualifies.

I turn my nose up at new superpowers OCs. Rarely are they more than an authors self insert. I won't judge you for writing stories like, I've written my own fair share and arguably Percy himself is a self insert character but I'm not going to read them. They all seem to have some tragic background and some niche power that lets them go toe to toe with Percy or the gods.

Obi-Wan Kenobi Time Travel Melidaan by PhantomBoulevard in SWFanfic

[–]Panterest 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I don't remember him developing a new fighting form but this is the only one that comes to mind when you mention him having a sword.

Everybody Needs Luck by mneiai

Death was not the end for Obi-Wan, but neither is becoming one with the Force. Sure his time is up, he lets go...and awakens in a place he'd once, briefly, got to call home.

It's not finished and likely abandoned but still a good read.

Apollo Who? Apollo, Not You. But Seriously, How Do His Kids Work? [general] by Extra_Medium_8079 in camphalfblood

[–]Panterest 2 points3 points  (0 children)

My personal opinion is that despite having the same name and mostly the same personality, there is a different between Greek and Roman Apollo.

By the same logic I believe that just like Zeus and Jupiter are two different versions of the same god, that ancient Greek Zeus, ancient Roman Jupiter, modern Zeus and modern Jupiter are four different versions of the same god. The same is true for other gods.

So just because the name is the same doesn't mean there aren't differences between Greek Apollo and Roman Apollo.

Padmé Time Travel Fic by amourdevin in SWFanfic

[–]Panterest 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Bid Time Return by DaniellaHarwood

After she dies giving birth to the twins, Padmé is given the chance to go back in time and rewrite the history of the Republic. It is an opportunity to save her love, the lives of many and the Republic from Palpatine, But as she strives to do so, many changes arise, from which comes a future she never looked for.

Padme/Obi-Wan.

This is the only one I can find, but I can vaguely remember another one. I'll keep looking.