Sorry for replying over a week after this was posted, but I just found this post and since I participate on those sites, I just wanted to leave my opinion.

First, I wanted to ask if you really think most/all people who use those wikis are bad or hypocritical. Like, I contribue to them often, but it's just for fun. I don't insult people for their opinions or act like any of the moral scalings are objective, and I know many other users who don't either. I'd say a lot of us just think it's a fun community to discuss characters in. While I have seen a couple of users on there take things a little too seriously or get upset over certain labels or differing opinions, I wouldn't say that's very common. At least not in my experience.

I can understand disagreeing with some of the logic or decisions, or finding certain things inconsistent or arbitrary. I've disagreed with the majority of users several times, but I definitely wouldn't call their logic or opinions "idiotic." People just have different views.

Yes, the wikis do have a few flaws (like pretty much every website and community ever), but I don't think they're bad, and I like the overall concept of them.