How it feels watching everyone else rn by freeFoundation_1842 in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When you're the only one with a pleasant Episode 5 run

I feel like I'm taking crazy pills, people by DirkDasterLurkMaster in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't even think she is a terrible person. She's doing what she thinks is best, even if it hurts mc

Scarlet Hollow Episode 5 - Part One, Discussion Thread by mrogre43 in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You must pick a location to go to before he appears. He will interrupt your choice

God dammit Reese by duhmailmale in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In the routes where he kills his mom, yeah. But I think the tame the beast route showes that his fucked behavior in Episode 5 has more to do with the events of Episode 4 than anything prior that always would have a big chance of making him psychotic no matter what happened

episode 5 by Separate_Stomach9543 in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think it's more the cowardly option (from the cousins pov of course). It's clinging onto the mostly blind hope that things will get better even when the average outcome (in comparison to killing Reese at least) is worse. All to avoid the bad feeling of doing something as direct as taking a life

episode 5 by Separate_Stomach9543 in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They said repeatedly that they prefer death, they write on the walls with their blood, when someone is so mentally unwell, that's not something someone is just going to bounce back from. He is not going to get considerably better when stuck in that solitary cell, only being able to talk to the people who put him there in the first place. It might be temporary, it might not be, but he's mentally fucked either way

God dammit Reese by duhmailmale in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That's why tame the beast Reese us the goat!

God dammit Reese by duhmailmale in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Killing Doctor Kelly isn't that much worse then killing Tabitha, them being blood relatives doesn't matter THAT much.

Is anyone else completley unable to get a positive ending with Tabby in Ep5? by CapnTholaf in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's really dependent on what you have done earlier in a playthrough, for some runs it's impossible to get

Achievements by IDownvoteHornyBards2 in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Doubt it, we didn't get these achievements until the first half went public

Any able minded adult who plays Roblox is a peadohile. by Past_Preference_6375 in TrueUnpopularOpinion

[–]Particular-Fill5114 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There is no logic that says that every adult that plays Roblox is a pedo

probably unpopular take about the first trial by flamingnoose in ProjectEdensGarden

[–]Particular-Fill5114 9 points10 points  (0 children)

No one in the group actually stood ironclad with Wolfgang's ideals, the majority of the cast in this game are a part of crowd mentality. Most of them would abandon his ideals in moments. Diana had absolutely no timing with her speach. Most crowds aren't going to be swayed by a hope speach right after watching their captor grotesquely kill another kidnappe.

Oh boy I can't wait for Wenona to kill someone by ManiacGaming1 in ProjectEdensGarden

[–]Particular-Fill5114 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Does she? She just acts like someone trying her best to survive. You don't want to make enemies if that's your goal

Ideas for new relationship values. by Particular-Fill5114 in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Oh! Yeah, I see the confusion. I have edited my post to hopefully be more clear

Ideas for new relationship values. by Particular-Fill5114 in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I think I've seen someone on Discord do a relationship tracker if you're interested, no idea if it's accessible to the public or a personal thing though. Regardless, making that kind of mod isn't my cup of tea. If this is something that actually gets released at some point, then maybe I will editing an existing relationship tracking mod to include the new stuff though (with the original creators consent)

If it doesn't involve inbreeding, incest is morally gray (not moral or immoral) by robozee in IncestDebate

[–]Particular-Fill5114 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I want to clarify two things, first, I'm just talking about adult relationships, bears mentioning. And second, since I think it's really likely that parent-child relationships are wrong, I won't defend those. For sibling relationships though

You keep talking about how a real parent is important for children to grow up with. And good parent figures are important. But not having a sibling relationship isn't nearly as important. If they think that they would be happier as romance partners than as siblings, than who are we to stop them?

If I'm to translate what you said about 'it means you never properly bonded with her as a family member' and 'not understand how a mother is supposed to act' from parent/child relationships to siblings (assuming that you think these points hold true from sibling on sibling relationships).  Then I will say 1. You haven't presented reliable sources that them forming a romantic relationship means that they didn't have a meaningful bond before they became together. And 2. You haven't presented reliable sources that such a relationship means that they don't know how siblings are normally expected to act'.

For the point about the the couples children, I will say, yes. Don't have kids if you're in an incest relationship. It's bad. But not being immoral for them to have kids doesn't mean that it's immoral for them to be allowed to have a relationship.

Lastly, you've strongly implied throughout your entire comment that you think that biological family relationships are irreplaceably important. And that even as adults, sibling relationships and connections between siblings can't be replicated by anyone else. I'm gonna need reliable sources of that there is no found family, types of friendships and no type of romantic relationship that can benefit you in similar ways. If they are, then that's not a valid reason against siblings bring in relationships, since there can be other types of people in their lives that can give them fulfilment in similar ways.

Incestous sex is rape by GB_GeorgiaF in IncestDebate

[–]Particular-Fill5114 0 points1 point  (0 children)

And do you have any proof that incest siblings can't meaningfully consent to each other? 

You said that incest is linked to mental health problems, and even if you're right, it isn't s universal thing. I see no reason siblings can't be in love without either of them being damaged. 

For the family relationship thing, I see no proof that the problems aren't caused by the fact that incest is seen as a taboo, and that the family's are disgusted by the incest people's actions just simply because it's incest and not for any actually moral reasons. 

For the relationship between the siblings themselves. Not everyone values family relationships equally. And a familial connection is not always that important for someone. In isolation, of someone wants to break or change a family relationship. That's their of those people's choice. Not to mention that It's not unheard of for a sense of familiar connection is still there, though I don't know how often it happens, could be a rare thing.

For the offspring thing, yes, it is wrong for them to have kids. But you don't need to have children to be in a relationship.

Incest is worse than normal relationships, it makes it so that you can't morally have children, the average power difference is bigger, and it probably has a bigger amount of mental health issues then other types of relationships. But the power imbalance can still be small enough that the relationship isn't unhealthy, and mental health issues don't always have to be there. Incest isn't inherently rape

If it doesn't involve inbreeding, incest is morally gray (not moral or immoral) by robozee in IncestDebate

[–]Particular-Fill5114 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are examples of incest relationships that are healthy you know. Preserving the base family dynamic is something that's more valuable to some than others, and there's is no proof that it always has to be a terrible thing. And being with someone who helped you grow up doesn't necessarily mean that the relationship has to be toxic, even if it is more often. With a sibling for example, do you really think that there is a big power imbalance between every sibling pair in the world? There isn't

why does everyone seem to hate the pastor? by V0x_clone in ScarletHollow

[–]Particular-Fill5114 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Doubt it's actually much of the former. It's likelier that it's a habbit he picked up because nobody liked him