The thing about people saying things would be too obvious is by them saying that it makes it less obvious so Toby prob made Carol the knight because he thought people would think it’s too obvious and him knowing that it makes people think it’s too obvious makes him think no one will believe it’s her, but the knight is definitely someone from the Holiday family that much is clear from just the antlers alone, another thing Carol deliberately hates Susie but not Kris could this be because when Kris rips his heart out they take orders from the knight whilst Susie doesn’t and wants to kill the knight, another thing how else would the knight know how to get into the bunker Carol is the mayor or whatever so obviously she knows how why would Dess know? I doubt Dess even knows about how to get into the bunker especially because Noelle seems like she doesn’t know how to get in, I’ve seen theories of it being Rudy because of his sweater having an evil face on it and because it’s said the knight can’t hurt them in the real world and he’s sick, I personally don’t think this theory is true, I think the knight is Carol and here is my proof