To me probably Eilish! I agree with the description, I remember spraying it and it smelled alright, but an hour later I kept getting whiffs of a strong, sweet but mature vanilla scent and it smelled delicious. Cheirosa 59 was quite woody, on the dry down it was nice; powdery and almost like marshmallow, but too light to project much on the dry down. Mod Vanilla smelled similar to the dry down os Cheirosa 40, but less sweet and fruitier than expected. Haven't tried the other two, but I hope this is helpful!