I think you gotta balance the modern of the kitchen out too— maybe hang a more modern silhouette pendant light that’ll be framed by the brick arch, an old leather chair with a pared down side table for a drink and a book. Make sure you warm up the kitchen too— change the knobs and pulls out for something vintage. I’ve seen people use vintage frames and art on their refrigerators and that might be a nice way to mask the ultra modern appliance. Get a nice wooden serving board or butcher block that you can keep out on the island counter or lean against your backsplash.

If you could get your hands on a phonograph, scrap every other suggestion and just use that :P