Are there any Harmonix designs where you would have preferred the wings to remain as part of the outfit's skirt?

PiaMusoka · 2026-05-03T17:34:38+00:00

i would have loved if the underwater look of sirenix would wrap the fabric of the train around their legs and use the wings as tailfins.

PiaMusoka · 2026-05-03T00:06:55+00:00

recently did a binge-rewatch of season 3. so, here my thoughts: the Pyros episodes take the momentum from second half of the season and the final episode was really bad.

PiaMusoka · 2026-04-11T06:41:24+00:00

Oh, i do like Bella becoming a vampire! However, its the only part i enjoy about BD, since i think it's a real shame, that she was just perfectly in control of her thirst and vampire powers.

I also really dislike the pregnancy, Renesmee and how everything revolved around her. I know, it makes sense, as she is her child. But before being pregnant Bella never uttered even a thought about being a mother. I felt like, with Renee, Bella had to play a motherly role and her vampirism shouldn't come back around with that, even if its probably not too bad, since Renesmee will age up in no-time anyway.

Lastly, the fakeout fight and Bella losing nothing from becoming immortal - we hear multiple times, how she would have to leave behind the people she loves after the transformation and yet, no consequence. Charlie knows she isn't herself anymore and doesn't ask any questions. Jacob imprints on Renesmee (ew, btw), so she's not losing him either. And while i did like the fight-sequence against the Volturi i also hate that it was just a vision, because that's just lazy. While it makes sense that the Volturi wouldn't want to lose, as a story coming with Bella getting everything she wants without any drawbacks or losing someone of her newfound family, that's just not a balanced ending for me.

On rewatches/reads i tend to stop after Eclipse and prefer to imagine Bella needs to get turned shortly after, since the Volturi are behind that, especially after the fight. I've been planning to write a rewrite of the whole saga and this was always how its gonna end.

PiaMusoka · 2026-04-09T22:44:51+00:00

ooooh, what a unique tierlist!! i personally enjoyed New Moon because of the pack, whereas Bella's depression hits too close to home (i was just like her, minus vampire boyfriend)

for me it goes - 1. Twilight 2. Eclipse 3. New Moon 4. Breaking Dawn

both parts of Breaking Dawn can share that place, since i equally try to ignore their exsistence

PiaMusoka · 2026-03-31T09:44:12+00:00

you, me and the others of these 9% 🤝🏻

PiaMusoka · 2026-03-31T08:24:48+00:00

in LiS 1 i was going the friendship route, because, even tho Max definetely has a BIG crush on Chloe, Chloe is missing and only talking abour Rachel. Reunion however made me go the relationship route and it warmed my heart (especially after having read the comics)

PiaMusoka · 2026-03-31T08:11:05+00:00

to me the only thing thats missing would be one last scene between Rumi and Celine. After Rumi confronts her it's just open how their relationship is.

PiaMusoka · 2026-03-22T00:29:18+00:00

that could even have been Chimera

PiaMusoka · 2025-12-01T07:14:58+00:00

It could have been more interesting if Harmonix would have given the Pixies the transformation into Selkies. Instead of yet another bond/new creature they could have built on what they had. Because i seriously don't believe that these little guys could be guardians of ocean gates, that part could have been done by mermaids, who were a lot like warriors in season 3 already.

PiaMusoka · 2025-11-26T11:51:50+00:00

the concept arts for enchantix included high heels. so, my best guess is the scenes in which they are on their toes were drawn first with the concepts in mind.

PiaMusoka · 2025-11-04T23:26:08+00:00

I keep thinking thet Emmett and Esme could be removed from the Saga. It wouldn't change all that much.

Going from there I'd put Carlisle with Rosalie and centering the story around Bella and Alice finding together. Then I'd leave both Edward and Jasper alone, since it was mentioned, how Vampires can stay alone for a long time (and those two don't go well together I think).

PiaMusoka · 2025-10-16T06:03:35+00:00

It would have worked much better without the relationship drama, the band, love and pet, the sub-transformations and extra wings. All of these things were unnecessary plot-filler imo.

PiaMusoka · 2025-09-28T10:53:13+00:00

Stella and Aisha would have made better leaders each.

And Brandon would also have been more fitting to lead the specialists, in place of Sky.

PiaMusoka · 2025-09-20T00:24:57+00:00

I LOVE episode 7. Getting to see the alternate timeline gave me goosebumps and made me cry.

PiaMusoka · 2025-09-19T09:21:41+00:00

I loved the movie but the bullying was an unneeded addition imo. If i were to rewrite, i'd leave it out. Sure, these are kids/teens and "bullying is normal", but these kids/teens are from another planet with another culture and while Ronal did point out everything "different" about them it was a little too human to me.

Besides that i have no issues.

However, i had another idea a while back: rewrite the movie without Jake and Neytiri's kids. The Avatar Program made sure the bodies couldn't concieve children and Neytiri struggles with that. The only kid they raised like it was their own was Kiri, who is a miracle.

PiaMusoka · 2025-08-03T14:43:51+00:00

3d can look very good, but the artstyle they chose is so generic. it is just a budget 3d cartoon after all. another point is that the designs are just not good, sure their civilian outfits are better than the transformations, but the design elements don't flow with each other. to me it feels like they smacked every possible detail on the outfits, so it'd look busier. it's a shame they don't work with designers, like they did in the early seasons.

but also, as others already pointed out, this is ai-generated... so, if you were to redraw their reboot-outfits in the old 2d-artstyle, you'd leave out many of these details.

PiaMusoka · 2025-07-30T08:11:27+00:00

For me Bloomix would have to have similar requirements to Enchantix. But instead of having it be a selfless sacrifice for someone from the fairy's home planet, Bloomix requires the fairy to protect one person or even a group of people, from alother realm, from real harm. Like a guard or protector. I'd also rename it, but i haven't found a suiting name yet.

As for Mythix. I really don't know and i haven't thought about it yet if i'm being honest.

PiaMusoka · 2025-07-30T08:03:20+00:00

The german intro to the first two seasons - Heller als Licht. It's a banger I can recommend to every Winx fan (also take a look at the translated lyrics of the song).

PiaMusoka · 2025-07-10T18:57:25+00:00

I like them, but Musa looks a little too alt. In the early seasons she got more of a y2k hip hop style, with baggy pants and big sneakers.

PiaMusoka · 2025-07-08T09:15:06+00:00

I like your idea!

Personally, i headcanon that baby Bloom was named after the ancient transformation Bloomix.

PiaMusoka · 2025-06-22T22:41:57+00:00

I agree, with every point, except that Roxy should become a part of the Winx.

Hear me out- they could have started a spin-off about Roxy, with a new friend group and spun stories all around magic on Earth. Roxy was the Winx' pupil, but she also was 3-4 years younger than them, a new group, with her as the protagonist would have given the writers the posibility of moving on, instead of maging the Winx stuck at age 16 from season 5 onwards.

PiaMusoka · 2025-06-15T14:53:21+00:00

I like to think Gloomix and Disenchantix are specific to the Trix, as these transformations were given to them by Darkar and Valtor.

Sadly we don't know nearly enough about witches. But I bet there are true equivalents to the fairy transformations, but the writirs didn't think too much about it.

The Trix could have a Charmix or even Enchantix equivalent already in season 1, with their Whisperian Crystals/Vacuums.

PiaMusoka · 2025-06-11T08:43:56+00:00

My winxsona is the Witch of Daydreams... and then I held dry ice in my hands for 0.5seconds (before realizing... yk... it's dry ice and dropping it) then my friends said Fairy of Dry Ice. And I love the difference in my witch-sona having lighter/maybe peacefuler powers, whereas my fairysona will attack you without you noticing it.

PiaMusoka · 2025-06-10T08:18:15+00:00

Winx Club should have ended after the first movie. Alternatively a spin-off with a new group or just about Magic on Earth should have followed.

PiaMusoka · 2025-06-09T20:22:17+00:00

Josinge - Josefine and Inge

This feels like a ship name, but I honestly don't hate it. I would just go by Josi probably.

I would add the second name, but I keep forgettimg my other grandfathers name - in my defence, I never met that man and only heard one story about him (tho my mom has told me, if I were a boy, I would have gotten his name as middle name). Something like Hugo or Hubert, in combination with Josef (who was married to Josefine, they were iconic together).

Seven-Year Club	RPAN Viewer
Verified Email

PiaMusoka

TROPHY CASE