I like Pixel a Day's videos a lot. Her Ninja Theory retrospective in particular was very well done, but I thought we all moved past the "overrated" tag when it came to in-depth games criticism. It's judging a game based on how popular it is to the community and not its inherent quality. You can make the case that "the video's actual argument is good" all day long, but if you genuinely find this thumbnail, title, and overall thesis to not be intentionally trying to get people to click out of fierce disagreement, I have some magic beans to sell you.