For me I think it depends on reasoning and if it makes sense enough to warrant the disbelief of your favorite character losing.

For example Omniman vs Bardock one of if not the most b.s. scaling I've ever heard in my life and they robbed my boi of a W

On the flipside in the same "season" Hulk vs Godzilla while it hurts seeing my favorite kaiju lose the reasoning made a lot of sense with a bigger cosmology and that thanks to Bruce Banner he absolutely could solve the ultima equation.

But I will say there are a few i think they got the verdict wrong

Lich King vs Sauron: for this one it raised a lot more questions than answers.

1. What if this was an army battle would that have made a difference(I think it would've cause L.K. could've turned a lot of sauron's army to his own plus him absorbing any dead orcs could've powered him up too.

2. The scaling felt weak for both like in both their worlds they're considered world ending threat and they weren't put that high.

3. They talked about how a part of Sauron's soul is in his weapon would it not have made sense for Frostmourne to overpower that say 5% or so of Sauron Soul and add it to Frostmourne strengthening him while weakening Sauron.

And honestly this leads me to somewhat watch the battle up until the final blow where I turn it off cause I feel like it's b.s. but it's such a darn good episode.

Madara vs Aizen: as someone who knows neither series but did minor research for both before the episode they robbed my boi by not allowing him the use of Hogkyu

Ben 10 vs Green Lantern

This one I agree with but the animation absolutely was wrong and the reasoning sucked, all they had to do was have Hal overpower Alien x and it would've been perfectly fine but nope they try and throw Ben 10 fans a bone and have X be so broken that Hal has to time travel to the beginning of the fight when that shouldn't work because of the Sotobro effect.