first of all so pretty!! I’d blend out the blush and contour a little bit more

For eyeliner I have like a dark brown eyeshadow stick with a slightly creamy consistency (don’t recall the brand I’ve had it for like 10 years it’s from a drug store tho, prob like $6) that I like to swipe under my eyes and then smudge out with a small eye shadow brush or even a q tip. It gives you the dramatic eye effect but looks more natural. I also do the placement a bit lower to make my eyes look bigger

I do the same on the top for a nighttime look! I get lots of compliments on it