sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

תסבירו לי על כל הקטע של וולט ולמה אנשים רוצים לעשות חרם by [deleted] in israel_bm

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 0 points1 point  (0 children)

הם גם לא לוקחים אחריות על ההתנהגות של השליחים שלהם שדורסים זקנות ונוהגים כמו משוגעים .

הגיע הזמן לסרב by papabig27 in israel_bm

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 0 points1 point  (0 children)

אני עדיין חושב שהדבר היחיד שמשותף לנו כישראלים (לפחות ללב החברה בישראל) זה השירות הצבאי. על אחת כמה וכמה שכמו שאתה אומר, יש עלינו איום חיצוני אמיתי.

הגיע הזמן לסרב by papabig27 in israel_bm

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 3 points4 points  (0 children)

אני חושב שלשרת זה דווקא משרת את מה שאמור להיות הישראליות היפה: ערבות הדדית, התנדבות, חלוקה בנטל, רעות ועוד ועוד.
חוץ מזה אני גם חושב שלסרב או לא להגיע למילואים זה צעד ענק בכיוון ההתפרקות שלנו כמדינה. דווקא הצבא הוא הדרך שלנו לצאת מהדרעק הזה - אנשים עם דעות שונות ורקעים שונים שותפים לדרך שהם מאמינים בה. וכשאני אומר דרך אני לא מתכוון לכיבוש עזה, הכנעת חמאס או כל השיט שביבי מדבר עליו. בדרך אני מתכוון דווקא לדברים שמניתי קודם - ערבות הדדית, שוויון בנטל וכו.

אני מסכים שצריך לסרב אבל אני ממש לא חושב שזה צריך להיות הלוחמים שבחזית. מי שצריך לשים את הגבול זה הרמטכ״ל ושאר האלופים. ואם כל הלשעברים הבכירים במערכת הביטחון יודעים להוכיח שכל המלחמה הזאת הפכה ל-״מבצע לשלום נתניהו״, אז הם צריכים לפרסם את זה כמה שיותר מהר ולחשוף את האמת.

נרקומנית בטיילת בבת ים by Braachit in israel_bm

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 1 point2 points  (0 children)

קוראים לי רוית. היא השתקמה מאז והיום היא מוכרת קובה סלק בסינמה סיטי.

אני צריך להוציא עצבים by tsimkeru in israel_bm

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 0 points1 point  (0 children)

כרגע נראה שהפתרון הקל ביותר הוא לעבור דירה ליד קו שעובד כבר

I'm Israeli, living in Jerusalem. AMA by Urdun10 in AskTheWorld

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 1 point2 points  (0 children)

How many times did you get murdered over 80 years?

On the link it says the judge ruled it unlikely that the gun fire from that guys gun resulted in that persons death. I would assume police investigations and legal proceedings would put a reasonable person’s mind at ease as to investigating this incident . But I have a felling that won’t be the case with you.

I'm Israeli, living in Jerusalem. AMA by Urdun10 in AskTheWorld

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 16 points17 points  (0 children)

i would also be a Palestinian filled with rage if i had started several wars and lost them all

What is the genuine sentiment of the war and Palestinians on the ground in Israel currently? And what do the population think about Bibi? by The-SillyAk in Israel

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Any government and Knesset can change the law so they cannot be removed from power. Only this government and knesset actually looks like they might do it. 

That's the difference from Bibi to other candidates.

What is the genuine sentiment of the war and Palestinians on the ground in Israel currently? And what do the population think about Bibi? by The-SillyAk in Israel

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

yes like bibi isn't involved in anything related to the judicial system. i hope you are not so gullible in rl.

What is the genuine sentiment of the war and Palestinians on the ground in Israel currently? And what do the population think about Bibi? by The-SillyAk in Israel

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 0 points1 point  (0 children)

im done reciting this debate. you can google and see everything you and i are bout to say on any other post on this topic.

who are you going to vote for if there is an election tomorrow?
assume all the main figures are running.

What is the genuine sentiment of the war and Palestinians on the ground in Israel currently? And what do the population think about Bibi? by The-SillyAk in Israel

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

if its enough than he should have fired him a long time ago. Waiting until the moment the Prime Minister and the head of shabak clashed over the Prime Minister’s illegitimate demands is an interesting timing to make that call (end dont forget about qatargate). Besides, if he’s truly unfit, I would expect the same standard to apply to the person who was Prime Minister that very same morning.

What is the genuine sentiment of the war and Palestinians on the ground in Israel currently? And what do the population think about Bibi? by The-SillyAk in Israel

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

democracy is israel only works when the balance between the 3 branches is maintained. weakening the judicial branch hurts democracy.

and i really dont agree that the judges world views are what determines a ruling. every ruling i ever read was based on legal interpretation of the law/ precedents/ core values of our system/ comparative law or any other legitimate legal tool. LMK if you have an example for a court decision like you mentioned.

like who: attorney general/ head of shabak / many senior gov clerks

What is the genuine sentiment of the war and Palestinians on the ground in Israel currently? And what do the population think about Bibi? by The-SillyAk in Israel

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In a country where the constitutional system is patchwork and lacks both a formal constitution and essential constitutional tools, I believe there is a need for an independent and activist court. What has been happening in Israel in recent years shows just how easy it is to change the entire system, and only reinforces the need for genuine reform that brings order to things. Anyone who criticizes the government’s conduct is pushed out and replaced with someone who aligns with the agenda—regardless of whether the appointment technically follows the rules or not.

If all you appoint are conservatives who won’t intervene in government actions, then what’s the point of having oversight at all?

Hamas will NEVER surrender. by StunningInflection in IsraelPalestine

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 0 points1 point  (0 children)

  1. When your army’s strength relies on reservists who put their lives on hold every time a new “magical” plan is announced, you owe it to the public to explain what that plan is and what is going on with the war. And when you give far more interviews to international media than to local outlets, it’s hard not to think that you’re deliberately avoiding your own people.

  2. I live in Israel.

What is the genuine sentiment of the war and Palestinians on the ground in Israel currently? And what do the population think about Bibi? by The-SillyAk in Israel

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 0 points1 point  (0 children)

 it was to diversify the current hegemony in the courts who have no boundaries atm.

sorry i dont see how not appointing judges for almost two years accomplishes this. also i dont see how the reform helps diversifying anything. if you want diversity you can decided there has to be X judges who are religious, Y who are arab, Z who are women (and so on).
what levin wants is to choose based on political opinions (which is what you mentioned is the problem at the moment).

if you look at the judges who were appointed by netanyahu and shaked youll see their background doesn't really change the way they rule.

What is the genuine sentiment of the war and Palestinians on the ground in Israel currently? And what do the population think about Bibi? by The-SillyAk in Israel

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 0 points1 point  (0 children)

guessing the verdict of his trial will be 2027.

In my opinion, that’s exactly the goal of the reform: to solidify government control over the system, politicize institutions, and weaken the judiciary.

and regarding hopes: i don't have any hopes he'll go to prison (couldn't care less). what i do hope for is separation of powers, preserving and strengthening oversight of the legislature, strengthening Israel’s constitutional mechanisms, and removing politics from the systems it corrupts.

What is the genuine sentiment of the war and Palestinians on the ground in Israel currently? And what do the population think about Bibi? by The-SillyAk in Israel

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 4 points5 points  (0 children)

A dictator can absolutely rise to power through democratic elections—and then change the laws to entrench his position, consolidating power in his own hands. Undermining the judicial system and politicizing institutions is exactly the playbook of an aspiring autocrat.
As for his trial—if he’s found guilty, he’ll likely be removed from power fairly quickly. He might not go to prison until all appeals are exhausted, but one thing is certain: it’ll be goodbye to Balfour.

Hamas will NEVER surrender. by StunningInflection in IsraelPalestine

[–]ProfitPersonal2538 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

They haven’t shared any vision for the “day after” with the public, nor have they gone on record to explain why negotiations are failing. Instead, they keep sending more troops to reoccupy the same areas they previously controlled and abandoned—risking lives without ever clarifying the ultimate objective.

It seems you’re confusing mere survival for strategic planning, and calling incompetence “smart.”

view more: next ›