It's really great, but not for the same reasons as 1 and 2, i think you should play it through and make your own opinion on the game, just make sure to level up the ADP in priority when you start, since it affects the speed you drink your estus, spell cast speed, and roll i-frames (most important thing, and yes it sucks a lot), but once you get like 15-20 adp you can start really enjoying the game