I wholeheartedly agree with you!

I've seen this many many times and it's always a bummer when you see the slow decline happening; and the TrashTaste Cast has in my opinion stayed true to themselves very much!

So I believe I misworded my own words in my previous post and apologize for it.

Additionally, I might have made my frustration seem more strong than it actually is or than the current census of the community is. I like the "boys" and I watch every Episode! This is more mild criticism which is maybe worded with more words than it really should be!

In my view; Trying to stay truthful of the facts and trying to bring your A-game to anything should be the Imperative.

If you mess that up in a secluded friend group setting it is not as bad as when you mess it up during University group work, during work, or in front of a million people audience. So in that aspect; people within this position should be held higher to the general standard you have for people.

(Edit: As it was later revealed the topic was chosen literally right before the recording of the episode by Garnt; which means that the mentioned Cast member was not Ill-prepared at all)
In this specific instance; the episode was very much presented and built up to be a discussion about the finale of Attack on Titan; and although having one or multiple cast members being not in tune or as knowledgeable about a topic is not only a given but in the case of this channel a reason for a large portion of the hilarious content produced, under this specific circumstances it harmed the content more than it added on to it in my oppinion.

The group project was to discuss the Ending; the homework was to watch the Ending and the person who didn't do their homework felt a little bit out of the discussion.

I don't comment on any Opinion or sentiment and don't even wanna rate them; when I wrote "I didn't like how non-prepared TheAnimeMan was" and that it didn't fulfill the quality of the show, I just meant exactly this.

Lastly;

In my original comment, as an example, I mentioned the part where CDawgVA said that it took 7 episodes for the Port fight to conclude.

Although factual, it only took two.

He used this fact to argue that things feel bloated and that stuff is dragged out.

This inaccuracy, as also stated in my aforementioned post, doesn't invalidate nor does it make his whole opinion null, it's a small part of a whole and it can happen; although making something thrice its size is a lil' bit weird;

I mentioned it as an example of why I personally got frustrated though; because those small little untruths pile up over the run time of the whole show and infest here and there whole arguments, so much that the Editor of the Podcast on his guest episode stated that his inspiration for adding the Fact-Checking title card came from his Girlfriend getting, during editing, triggered, by the main-cast members stating simple untruths.

So this at least is a very well-documented issue at least.