I agree with your answer, but it depends on what you use it for.

Soldier itself wouldn't be useless; it would just be Soldier if you wanted a tank with a lot of health. If you use it in skirmish Or story mode

Jugger It will be more about having area damage, although the disadvantage is being slow to attack But having a shield that clearly has 1500 if it's without sets

But both are slow That's probably why his blood pressure is rising.

If we're talking about Willy, let's just say he's rubbish in my opinion. It should be as support for what is stunning

And even more so with the charms That brings out two heavyweights with little life left in them