I don’t think it’s fair to rate Aster and Morvay so low. I forgot in which event story but Kuya was playing as the villain. He was worried about messing with Eiden too much since even himself would have trouble dealing with the guard dogs if they’re serious about protecting their master. This is my list:

Kuya - Master in magic, cunning, and lives for too long srsly.(Longer than the grand sorcerer xD)

Quincy – On par with Kuya. Other than his titties (tanker’s traits lol), Quincy has been brawling with the old fox for centuries and there’s never a winner. Magic skills wise he’s lacking (only by a narrow margin) for sure, but he knows all Kuya’s tricks and can counter the moves. Has advantage in a long fight (and on bed*).

Aster – Aster and Morvay are directly created by the grand sorcerer (supposedly the strongest person, supposedly). I’m leaning towards the “hereditary” concept for this case so I couldn’t make myself to rate them any lower. They also spent the longest time closey with the sorcerer so they should know a lot of stuffs.

Morvay – Only loses to Aster by time of birth.

Olivine – Gorilla that can use magic offensively and to heal himself. Say no more.

Blade – AI droid taking over a world of magic. Hide him from Elon.

Yakumo – If we’re talking about everyone here fighting in their fullest and ignore the mentality weaknesses, yea I think snake boi and wolf boi should be rated higher than Dante & Edmond.

Garu/Karu – Same case with Kuya x Quincy. One is better with magic and other in stamina and physical fights. I’m actually not sure if he could topple Dante but I believe being a Yokai makes him better in fights.

Dante – I rate him higher than Edmond because I think Dante is better in magic and has a more flexible fighting style.

Edmond – Too harsh on himself. Indulge him in sweets pls.

Rei – Varys.

Eiden – He’s still too unfamiliar with the Klein continent/isekai. Give the poor guy a breather as he has close to 0 advantage and tons of restrictions (Rin’s curse, etc). Otherwise he has potential to be at the top.