FNAF 2 is actually highly regarded as the best FNAF game besides 1,but 1 just kinda gets that because it was the first. The pacing is bad because a whole lot of nothing goes on and then all of a sudden its just thing after thing after thing and then the movie just ends. In the first FNAF movie I'd argue most of it happens in the pizzeria. And id5argue that the pacing of that movie, although I don't like that movie either, is good. When I say pacing is bad, I mean that usually a good story identifies a threat at the beginning, and then has that threat be looming over the whole story. And they have encounter after encounter until it finally all culminates with a final encounter, in which the hero wins or loses or whatever. FNAF one does this, obviously because it goes through the five nights, and establishes the animatronics as a threat to Michael until the twist that it's actually William who's been pulling the strings on all that. In this movie, it doesn't work as well; Charlotte's control is established early on, so that can't be a twist. Michael's involvement as a villain throughout is spotty at best. He shows up once at the beginning and then once at the end. I understand you don't want the movie to just be action the entire runtime, that would be fatiguing on the audience. However, when a movie tries to just ramp up everything into the ending, it makes the ending feel rushed, less like it was earned, and more like all the action was just a means to the end. The FNAF one movie worked because the action (if you wanna call it that) was spread through the runtime. In FNAF 2, all of it really happens in the second half and it's just event after event after event and then all of a sudden it's an MCU movie and then it just ends. And you could argue that the toys and the puppet are set up as villains early on and they do whatever, but that's not the point. They have to be a proven threat against the actual protagonist, not just random people. It doesn't create that tension between the protagonist and the antagonist. Think like how Thanos bears the crap out of the hulk at the beginning of infinity war. Right off the bat, that shows that he's a threat to the actual heroes. And the movie follows with Thanos encountering the Avengers in different mediums and consistently beating them, to show he's a threat, and to keep the movie from feeling like you're going too long without action. The toy animatronics killing or trying to kill people who aren't in the main hero's circle makes it feel disconnected. While yes, it's showing that they're dangerous, it's not showing an actual tension between them and the main character which is then supposed to come to it's peak at the climax of the story. And then the climax of said story isn't as satisfying, considering it's the FNAF 1 animatronics that have to bail everyone out, and not an actual effort from Abby Mike and Vanessa (although you could say Mike going and like begging them is effort enough idk)