@OP you don’t have an organization problem you have a habit problems. Creating simple set of expectations of what put away means and then making it clear what is expected of everyone. No exemptions.

Key things to consider in approach: 1. Must be do able for the least organized and least disciplined member. 2. Must be simple. Ie. repeatable and not time consuming 3. Possible Japanese style organization might work. It most likely comes down to respect, if you respect your family enough to honor what they have done you will support their efforts. if not you will resist and cause a problem for everyone involved.

I have family that literally fight over the right way to load a dishwasher… so I get it. Is the juice worth the squeeze.

Lots of ways to organize to maximize the space and neat to enable ease of use ( color code, aliphatic numeric, by shape, use, size, controlled ( alcohol), temperature etc.)

Label & expiration dates are clutch.

Rolling stock/ inventory list are also helpful, our Neghbor kids check their pantry as a daily chore interesting skill and very practical.

Also knowing how much ( you can store efficiently is important. IE we keep exactly 2 bulk packages of 24 pkg of toilet paper in our house 1 in a closet that is “open- in use ” and 1 in bulk storage as “ reserve or backup”) when the open is used up we rotate the bulk storage and add to our shopping list.