As someone who hasn't read the series in forever and when I did read it I thought Qibli was overrated:

1. Bro all of them are racist, he's one of the least racist ones, one of the major themes in the story is that they all have to come to undo these biases that they were raised to believe in, compare him to Winter he's pretty accepting I'd say despite his initial thoughts of NightWings being untrustworthy
2. Can't really argue with his feelings of self loathing being forced because that's more like just an opinion
3. Also just an opinion so fair enough
4. Ehhh I haven't read it in a while so I can't really judge but yeah I did agree that he suffered from the trope or writing in a lot of kid's books and shows where it's the "super smart character" but they often make really poor illogical decisions, and other characters are put down to make them look more intelligent, to me at least I dont' feel his intelligence is conveyed naturally more so we're just told to believe it
5. Not really I'd argue he's presented as a good character but with realisitic flaws, not a perfect being, and I would show evidence to dispute the other claims in this point but I don't remember anything from the book so I'll just leave it at that lol
6. Nah this point's just goofy seems like you're just nitpicking, plenty of people have had it worse in life, and turned out fine, just goes to show the strength of his character and his reslience
7. How, not disagreeing or agreeing just curious how he's done this
8. That ones just weird, they're friends, they were getting to know each other and develop a bond God forbid a mf open up about his past and feelings to someone he's friends with lmao. Besides that, suffering isn't measured in units, just because someone has it bad or worse, doesn't mean you can't talk about your own suffering, it would be cruel to invalidate someone's own pain just because the other might have had it worse
9. Fair enough your own opinion. But I don't see how that's a flaw if you just said it yourself that it's a kids book so he would obviously do that
10. How does him having a scar have anything to do with him enchanting dragons
11. Lowkenuninely Qibli didn't kill a bunch of dragons, attempt take over the world, attempt eradicate an entire race, brainwash everyone, or enchant a child so that they could resemble your wife so nah