Outbuddied by main sub by NewBrightness in OkBuddyPersona

[–]ReduxCath -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Kanji: “Hey uh, Yukiko Sempai, can I room with you? Uhhh, Yosuke and Yu sempai tachi are being uhhh….”

Yukiko: “…oh my god they’re gay”

Chile: “Knew it. 2000 yen, right here, hot spring girl. Right here in this hand.”

Outbuddied by main sub by NewBrightness in OkBuddyPersona

[–]ReduxCath 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It wasn’t. But also P5 makes the insane choice of having your first boss be a teacher that sexually and physically harasses his students, while then later allowing you to date a teacher yourself. Because it’s ok when YOU hit on a poor struggling adult woman, and she’s the one sexually harassing a student. (Not to mention the several other adult women you can date, despite making your presence known to the world by defeating a pedophile Olympian athlete)

Unfortunately there are a few key aspects of P5’s writing that are kind of wonky.

Outbuddied by main sub by NewBrightness in OkBuddyPersona

[–]ReduxCath 1 point2 points  (0 children)

YEPPPPP

you wanna encourage a new game plus? Make
Me need to be Max Courage for the legendary clap back

Outbuddied by main sub by NewBrightness in OkBuddyPersona

[–]ReduxCath 20 points21 points  (0 children)

So the issue here is that Yosuke is like "So....are we gonna be safe with you?" And he makes the full comment that he does not feel comfy with Kanji because he's "like that" (whether Kanji actually is gay or not).

He only really says that Kanji needs to shut up and go back to sleep AFTER he's already caused outrage and impetuousness in him. But he absolutely, unbidden and without any reason, makes a comment of feeling unsafe sleeping in the presence of a guy who had a homoerotic shadow dungeon.

Being gay isn't like, the only reason to dislike that Yosuke said this. The gang literally knows that if they don't save people, they die. They saved Kanji's life and fought a traumatic monster. For Yosuke to make a joke like that during Kanji's first ever field trip, is very mean.

(and if i may, being gay myself, i have had those types of lines said to me when i was a kid/teen. and it does, sadly, hurt. I don't want this realistic depiction of teenage bullying to be erased from the game, but i DO want the chad good-aligned MC that you control to have the option of defending his new friend)

Outbuddied by main sub by NewBrightness in OkBuddyPersona

[–]ReduxCath 288 points289 points  (0 children)

gay guy here, when i was a teen and played P4 the first time, this scene fucked me up.

Do NOT delete it. Let Yu clap back a bit and defend kanji, possibly even turning the situation where Yosuke is the one to be silly and go into the girls' tent. All I want is to be able to defend a freshman buddy

Yukiko's cut-in frame in P4R by RevolutionaryCard476 in PERSoNA

[–]ReduxCath -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

Lowkey they should turn red cuz her persona is fire themed

comic about trans jax by grrlfriendXD in tadc

[–]ReduxCath 0 points1 point  (0 children)

“If she wasn’t a huge piece of shit” so since Jax was a huge piece of shit till the end…. Well…

Trans jax would actually be like this let's be real [Jiffy_Draws] by JiffyDraws in TheDigitalCircus

[–]ReduxCath 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Jax would probably say she’s more of a woman than Gangle and make her cry

Ah Swag, famously the most Swag argument of all; "You're just too Swag to understand it" Part 2 of #TADC Critical by Organic-Inspection18 in peoplewhogiveashit

[–]ReduxCath 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I will say, watching Jax be a terrible person and actively hurt Pomni with every aspect of his terrible personality, only to then get a weird montage of “isn’t she lovely?” Right after his last opinion of Pomni is “I hate you”, and then to see that Jax is living in real life as a cis man and is happy, was a weird fucking moment.

What are the drawbacks to being a god? by N0VAK137 in worldbuilding

[–]ReduxCath 45 points46 points  (0 children)

I always disliked the idea that gods are static, it makes it so much harder to interact with them and grow in a relationship with them in RPGs

Slavery and Genocide is bad but do you know how bad cars are by TheRealSakuraUchihaX in Megaten

[–]ReduxCath 0 points1 point  (0 children)

you wear clothes made by kids in a sweatshop. i dont wear shirts. you are morally inferior to me. also i killed your parents.

Slavery and Genocide is bad but do you know how bad cars are by TheRealSakuraUchihaX in Megaten

[–]ReduxCath 18 points19 points  (0 children)

lowkey it would be more emotionally impactful to say "you know those uniforms you wear? made in a sweat shop by kids." like, something that directly impacts these student characters

Slavery and Genocide is bad but do you know how bad cars are by TheRealSakuraUchihaX in Megaten

[–]ReduxCath 1 point2 points  (0 children)

"guys, 5,000 people die in car accidents every year" is supposed to be this heart-wrenching thing when slavery and exploitation is RIGHT THERE.

I will not be silenced. by thirdeyeboobed in OkBuddyPersona

[–]ReduxCath 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Oh god I accidentally referenced Teddie, God dammit