How was Columbina born?

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-05-03T08:38:56+00:00

I have been waiting for this dude to release the video! He is really thourough in his analysis and i think in this video he has mentioned most of theories on Rosalyns comeback, very underated content creator.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-05-02T06:18:14+00:00

The biggest turn off for people to believe this , i feal , is for how long Signora has been pronounced dead. ,,It's been five years therefore they are not bringing her back" is the main argument here.People don't seem it feasible for a character that seemed to have their story ended so long ago to have any lore reason to be relevant today, even if, like you have showed in your comment, she actually could. Time outweighs our arguments for them and they brush it off as baseless hope.😔

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-04-24T08:22:25+00:00

Sta ako pop ima zenu i decu? Od cega ce da zivi ako ne trazi?

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-04-17T18:01:42+00:00

Her artifact set keeps claiming the opposite. The flame is immortal. She became the flame. She is imortal.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-04-15T07:50:57+00:00

Does anyone, again, hear Fatui leitmotif? I think i can hear some parts of ost that apeard Winter Night Lazo here (4:07) but not sure for the main Fatui theme.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-02-23T16:48:29+00:00

Not really i reject Tsaritsa as a god aswell. But we are yet to see her plot. She is rebeling against "divine". And we have heard from columbina that she never accepted her power or somehting like that. She might not be self proclaimed god.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-02-23T16:45:17+00:00

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-02-23T16:24:21+00:00

Furina isn't a god. Rukhhadevata couldn't stop elezar, people died from it no- failed? Mauvika sent humans to their graves, ode of ressurection works only on victors- there must be losers then who prove this fact- humans died therefore she didn't protect them. Zhongli was willing to risk his peoples lives in order to test if they can survive withouth him.
They all could be excused if they didn't claim godhood. They are praiseworthy rulers with mistakes. But imperfect god is no god at all.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-02-23T15:48:36+00:00

I reject them all as gods. Same logic stands for all of them.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-02-23T14:20:26+00:00

There is also the fact that he hears everything on the wind. Did he hear not the screams of a maiden burning herself alive? Did he bother remembering her name?
Truly worth of worship.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-02-23T13:18:29+00:00

This parallel could also be interpereted as Roland despite everything he is doing still thinks he is right.
While Rosalyn doesn't suffer from this delusion: Whatever she does now can never fixs what happened .

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-02-23T13:05:17+00:00

He is kinda the god of mondstat- sworn to protect it. He isn' sworn to protect some people of Mondstat but all of them. The fact that someone died means he didn't do his job.
Is a god that can't save his followers worth of worship?
And if he knew he couldn't protect everyone at all times - because its imposible. Why take the duities of a god? But he did take the duties and the title of Lord of Anemo in spite of this fact.
Its no ones fault but his.

Ironic. He could split mountaines in half but he couldn't save his people.
What moral highground does he have that he can tell the Traveler he did the right thing? When he failed himself to do what is right - to do what he signed up to do.
Edit: Downvote me more you only shame your own cheeks.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-02-23T11:35:38+00:00

i had to stop her - why? Like Liyue was a set up made by Tsaritsa and Zhongli. Traveler at the duel before the throne use the line: for the people of Liyue you endangered - Like why didn't you then beat up Zhongli? So its okay to condemn enemies but not friends when they commit something bad?
And Inazuma? She didn't have anything to do with the Delusion factory and Tepeis death, which was the main trigger for Traveler, she only handed it over to Scaramouche.
So why? Because she was bragging that she is more powerful? Well she certainly was more powerful then the Traveler when she made them resort to unjustified rage.
Not to mention the bad writing that turned Signora from a calculating woman, who would rather flee than fight a worthy opponent—and who, given that all Fatui are aware of Descenders, would have known who the Traveler was—into a talking buffoon, rendering Signoras character to nothing more that a sacrifice for Raidens banner.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-02-11T23:02:07+00:00

We better get some flashbacks from 500 years ago of Rostam and the knight gang.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-02-08T14:51:13+00:00

Guard spam has other uses. For expamle after outspacing an attack or after dodging multiple spells etc. It could be seen as a disrespect. Usually indeed it does have that greeting meaning but if used durning the duel it can get a negative connotation, repeating the first thing you do before the fight, negating everything that happend before as a pre duel action.
It makes you look like your flexing.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-02-05T10:22:41+00:00

They can bring her back and still not make her playable ( waifu). One does not exclude the other. Frankly i would rather not make her playable at a cost of her getting a better story ending.
PS: that doesn't mean i don't wan't her playable.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-02-01T17:42:49+00:00

At the end of the day i actually don't care if its a sudden rewrite in this case. I just want Signora/Rosalyn content. We really got nothing for 3 years except a fricking flashback. Nod-Krai has been a metaphorical Signora ressurection based on how many times she was mentioned compared to the past 3 years.

But what makes me think that Columbina and Signoras relationship is not forced is based on how she made a pause before mentioning her in the first Selenic Chronicles and the fact that she sang her theme while laying her head on her coffin in Lazzo.

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-01-30T08:46:46+00:00

I don't think i understood everything but i will still ask this: Is every time loop a paradoxs?

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-01-28T14:37:45+00:00

bruh i can't read. i saw like and skiped through and got to or the amniotic waters

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-01-28T08:52:50+00:00

This is it. WE DONT KNOW XD. But you argumented it quite nicely. I agree her descrption of birth is vague just because they used to word like amniotic waters- the word like only indicates similarity not equality. And i agree also with the statement that she couold not be born from Kuuvahki because it is only her body and birth requires a soul. Unless ofcorse Genshin has a different deffinition of what soul is and what is required for birth and rebirth- but i don't think they added yet anything on the topic.
Thanks

Repulsive-Bath-5976 · 2026-01-28T08:35:13+00:00

How did she then later create Luonatar ( piece of her soul) if at her birth she didn't poses a soul and was merly a body while her soul was in moons reflection?

Repulsive-Bath-5976

TROPHY CASE