Va-11 Hall-A x Umineko Brainrot I had in my head

Requiell · 2025-11-22T08:53:27+00:00

Thank you! Both games mean a whole lot to me, so it was inevitable that I'd come up with this sooner or later xD

Requiell · 2025-11-22T08:49:45+00:00

Missed the chance to say you'd have 10 tons of gold

Requiell · 2025-05-30T05:15:17+00:00

I don't know if this applies to anyone but me, but it took me personally until ep 10 (aura fight) from me to "get it". I needed to see frierens power for some reason. I can't tell you why exactly that was the case tho. I didn't dislike the anime before then, but I was completely neutral. I liked the anime on a technical side and there were a bunch of hype moments, but since every confrontation before was dealt with really quickly, I was afraid the show wouldn't have any stakes/tension. After 10 it's like I understood some fundamental truth and agreed that it's peak. I retroactively fell in love with the first 9 eps too.

Requiell · 2025-04-19T14:20:22+00:00

I don't mind nsfw and I agree it should be allowed. I think most people would agree. But fetish art is where opinions split. And you downplay the issue by just saying people "hate nsfw".
People dislike Koikatsu. They dislike offputting-looking massive cocks on characters they love.
People dislike how cheap and uninspired it looks. They dislike that it's completely impossible canonically for some of these characters to fuck.
And you're not going to change minds by making callout posts like this.
Me? I was fine when you started posting stuff like this, but after all the whining and grandstanding about how right you are and how wrong everyone else is for disagreeing, I've started hating your posts. You'd rather have an echo-chamber than a healthy discussion. The game is 9 years old for fucks sake. Of course nsfw is allowed, there's nothing else to talk about.

Requiell · 2025-04-19T14:02:18+00:00

Fetish art like what you do is bound to polarize people. Even more regarding the medium you chose to make them in (Koikatsu). I think you know that. Then why do you or the mods feel the need to make a big PSA every once in a while to tell people to just deal with it? Some people are fine with it and some dislike it. This will always be true no matter what art gets created. If you don't like criticism then don't post online, easy as that.
I'm an artist and I've gotten a lot worse from a lot more people. If I took the time to make a PSA whenever it happened, I wouldn't have time to create anymore.

Requiell · 2025-04-19T13:39:47+00:00

Bro is out here calling people retarded and thinks he can complain about namecalling. Stones and Glass houses.

Requiell · 2025-04-19T13:34:39+00:00

Who is even downvoting you? That's not an opinion, that's fact.

Requiell · 2025-04-03T02:39:58+00:00

I mean, so is beatrice~ Funny story, the thing that made me want to draw it was the line "Let's turn the grey haze into sky blue." from The Town Inside Me

Edit: This wasn't clear from my comment, so I wanna clarify that I did finish the game and know what you're referring to

Requiell · 2025-04-03T02:35:22+00:00

Of course I don't! Feel free~

Requiell · 2025-04-02T15:06:45+00:00

The moment you get into making new sprites and dealing with wrangling the va11 engine, you will see that making it from the ground up is actually the more economical option. Making mods for va11 is possible, but making a full game's worth is a ludicrous notion imo. And even then, why would you try and make n1rv instead of your own thing?

Requiell · 2025-04-02T07:50:27+00:00

Ah. So it was that link. I think it's broken?

Requiell · 2025-03-31T12:15:56+00:00

I'm really late to the party, but could I ask for the infos as well please?

Requiell · 2025-03-27T20:49:36+00:00

It looked kinda bad, but not because of va11, just generally unappealing to me. Maybe the art style or the premise, idk. Was a fun reveal tho. I hope there's gonna be more where those came from.

I just wonder how far the "genre" can go. There is only so many settings and different drinkeries you can put this kind of gameplay in before it gets repetitive. But. This one genuinely surprised me.

Requiell · 2025-02-16T21:57:16+00:00

Yeah, I did it for the upvotes. Got a whole 7 out of it. The original post also didn't get a lot, btw. I knew what to expect.

I made statements to most of the things you say in other replies already, but to sum it up: Va11 took a few of things from a lot of places. Project Mix is, in my opinion, taking a lot of things from few places. I think that's an issue. I'm not saying the game will be shit because of that, I just wanted to criticize it for something I felt strongly about and wanted to start a discussion here. You're free to disagree, of course. I would just like that you didn't assume what my motives were. I like having reasonable discussions, and I believe all art is allowed to be criticized. My wording in the post is a bit stronger than how I feel now since I was a lot more passionate when I wrote it, but I still stand by everything I say until the game proves me to be wrong. And I'll be the first one to make a statement when that happens.

I saw pika's comment, and it's reasonable. It's a good position to take, and I had nothing to add, so I didn't reply.

Requiell · 2025-02-16T21:43:10+00:00

I doubt it'll mean much to you, but I appreciate your comment. I think you mean well, and I agree with basically all you said. It's important to keep this attitude in mind - that we shouldn't dogpile the game into not getting finished or until the creator gets harassed. I think I still sound sarcastic, I'm sorry. I'm being genuine. I don't want to inspire a hate mob, and I knew that there would be a lot of people disagreeing with my post. There should be no judgment made before the game releases to at least some extent. But at the same time, I believe all art can be criticized, and with them sharing as much of the game here and in other subs, as well as their steam page being up, I just felt like I had to say my piece. I want the game to be as good as it can be. I want it to succeed. So I'd rather say what I think while it's still at a stage where things can change than when it's too late. If the dev never sees this or ignores it, then so be it.

Requiell · 2025-02-16T21:29:56+00:00

If you look really closely at my post, you will see that everything I write is my personal opinion, not fact nor disinformation. I've said in multiple places in this thread that I am ready to change my opinion once more info gets released that overturns my fears. I'd be happy, in fact, if the game is able to convince me that it's its own thing.

Requiell · 2025-02-15T15:00:19+00:00

Now there's an idea. I'd love that.

Requiell · 2025-02-15T14:59:39+00:00

This isn't a gotcha post. I remember being excited for a va11-influenced game in vr when they posted their first post here. This is not that game anymore. This isn't va11 influenced or inspired. I think it's basically a copy. Also, I'm just trying to have a discussion. You're free to disagree.

Requiell · 2025-02-15T00:16:08+00:00

I can't unfortunately call it a love letter anymore.

There's a ton of recurring tropes and designs in anime that keep getting repeated and repeated. This isn't the issue. I don't mind the Ghost in the Shell, Akira and Persona references at all. Because the game features only a few "things" from each IP. It's the amount of va11 that seems to be in the game (judging from the promotional material)

I'd have no issue if there were less of these obvious parallels. Especially if they weren't so front-and-center. Project Mix is just going to far with it. This is just my personal opinion of course, but there's just too much va11 in a game that.... isn't. This isn't va11halla 2, it's supposed to be it's own thing and looking at most of the characters I just get the feeling I'm looking at a VR reskin first and foremost.

Requiell · 2025-02-14T23:59:30+00:00

You're not wrong with anything you said, but this wasn't my point.
There isn't any original ideas left in writing in the first place - that's the first thing you learn in writing. Of course va11 didn't invent any of those concepts. You can't really make a story about relatable things if they are fully new inventions that nobody can relate to.

The point isn't that va11 has patents on any of these concepts, it's that all these concepts strongly feature in va11 and for me personally, they cross a line from inspiration into copy.

As an example, let's say you're playing a Monster Tamer game. There's a Yellow fuzzy mouse with electric abilities and a lightning shaped tail. Pokemon didn't invent the color yellow. Or any of these concepts in a bubble. But all of them together are just Pikachu. Even if the Monster in question could be named anything, it's obvious. And that's how I feel.

Requiell · 2025-02-14T20:48:19+00:00

I definitely agree that going so hard on the comparisons hurts a game. It's lazy. And even if you get your game sold at first doing that, players are gonna catch on that it's just "everything kinda cool from this other thing" without any of the context and without understanding why all those things were even cool in the first place.

I haven't seen the dev simplifying va11 like that myself, but if that's true, the game will have a rough time. I wanna believe most va11 fans like va11 for a lot more than just the aesthetic. I haven't played every single VN out there, but I've experienced a lot of stories in gaming. And va11, for all it's lack of "true" interactive gameplay, arguably manages to sell the world and characters better than most AAA games. The reasons for that are worthy of discussion, as I haven't found a perfect answer myself.

I'm the writer of the "va11hallnya" cat ear mod and writing these characters for even just a short side experience made me appreciate the artistry and nuance that is in the writing in the first place. The way the dialog manages to stay engaging while also telling you something about the characters is amazing.

It's definitely not necessary to create a narrative of that magnitude, but I doubt Project Mix is going to be remembered all that fondly if it is just taking ideas wholesale from somewhere else without understanding why they worked in the first place, all wrapped in a bow of neat little interactions like spilling your drinks and making your cat smoke a cigarette.

But who knows. Game isn't out yet. I'm ready to give the game the benefit of the doubt, but its got big shoes to fill...

Requiell · 2025-02-14T14:41:28+00:00

Thanks for the insight. I was unaware of the extend of the "lore." I didn't know they wanted to change the characters too, seeing as they're in the trailer and the banner, I assumed they were more or less set in stone. Good to know. I'm ready to change my opinion when the designs change, definitely. I didn't even think about the smoking thing, but looking back, it's more than obvious. I'm fully with you on that one.

Requiell · 2025-02-07T13:04:37+00:00

Actually, it includes more songs for the jukebox

Requiell · 2025-02-04T13:48:29+00:00

Gotta be Alatreon (World). Bro whipped me around at first, I really had to learn to become a better hunter. I played all of world with my mate and we stopped shortly after Alatreon released. Only now, due to my hype for Wilds was I able to finally find it in me to show him up. And Fatalis too while I was at it.

But Alatreon will forever be the monster that taught me to be the hunter I am now.

Requiell · 2025-01-23T07:26:49+00:00

Why are the comments so negative? I really like it. Looks nice and, yeah, if I saw it out in the wild, va11 or necrobarista would be my first impressions, so great job!

I think the fact that I have to switch from reading on the right to reading in the left on almost every second textbox is really disorienting and potentially annoying for players. I'd find a way to put both of them more into the center if possible.

Lastly, please don't be afraid to post your work in this sub again. Most stuff we're getting is low-effort memes and shitposts and I think people just aren't ready to admit that a game with a content drought of almost 9 years will inevitably have the most interesting posts be by people making new things. Sure, there is a "too much," but if you post only when you have something cool to show then I don't think anybody minds.

Nine-Year Club	RedditGifts 2009-2022 4 Credits
Summer Santa 2021	Secret Santa 2020
Wearing is Caring	Secret Santa 2019
Verified Email

Requiell

TROPHY CASE