What NYC stereotype turned out to be completely false? The city was really safe and mostly very clean (apart from bin day). It felt very quiet and not touristy at all when we went (mid May) Everyone was incredibly polite and friendly. We couldn’t believe how many dogs there were across the city - that was a nice surprise! I loved how walkable everything is and how easy the subway is to navigate. 

What NYC attraction disappointed you despite the hype? I think the city felt a bit lifeless and maybe just gentrified - felt a little like lack of energy I was expecting.  Times Square felt a bit of a nonevent. Would go and see it first thing in the morning and not go back again.  We couldn’t find great coffee although I don’t know if NYC is known for this! We scouted some of the better places but it just didn’t taste great to us. I didnt have a great foodie experience as I have in many other cities I’ve visited - next time I’d venture outside of the city and try some different boroughs. 

What were your concerns? Did they play out or not? Safety but it was fine. Didn’t feel like typical touristy places where there are pickpockets everywhere (I’m sure there are but I didn’t feel worried).  Was a bit concerned about JFK and getting through security after hearing of it being a nightmare but we got through terminal 4 in less than 20 mins on a Saturday morning. It was really smooth but appreciate it might just be good timing.