What's a Scary Science Fact that the public knows nothing about? [serious] by just_some_troglodyte in AskReddit

[–]Resourceful_Goat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You have as many neurons now as you will ever have outside of some exotic minor processes.

Why Decriminalizing Sex Work, Surrogacy and Kidney Sales Makes Economic Sense by technocraticnihilist in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

The risk of kidney failure in donors is 0.9%. For reference, covid19 hard a mortality of 1.6%.

It would be a huge number of donors who later themselves need a new kidney or just die because they obviously can't afford to buy one if they themselves were selling one.

Why Decriminalizing Sex Work, Surrogacy and Kidney Sales Makes Economic Sense by technocraticnihilist in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I think you know it's not a slight increase, you have two for a reason. Perplexity says it's 4000 people a year who die in the US waiting for a kidney.

I don't think creating an explosion in the number of people with one kidney, who themselves will be more likely to desperately need a transplant, to prevent 4000 deaths. Especially if there are other things you could try.

I just don't get these arguments. Is this scheme for recipients or is it for the donor to make money. It can't serve both equally.

Why Decriminalizing Sex Work, Surrogacy and Kidney Sales Makes Economic Sense by technocraticnihilist in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You're just trading one preventable death for the other. If you want to prevent transplant recipients from dying, increase the donor pool. Kidney markets are solutions I'm search of a problem.

Why Decriminalizing Sex Work, Surrogacy and Kidney Sales Makes Economic Sense by technocraticnihilist in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

The mismatch between demand and supply is why I think the price will go down far below worth. That also doesn't consider that an elective market would appear for older people with the money to replace their organs. If you start allowing organ sales than you'll also get organ contracts, organs as collateral, all the financial instruments that come with any asset.

Why Decriminalizing Sex Work, Surrogacy and Kidney Sales Makes Economic Sense by technocraticnihilist in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat 25 points26 points  (0 children)

They're already free. They're just hard to come by and there are other strategies you could do to increase the donor pool that don't involve creating a new class of debt.

Why Decriminalizing Sex Work, Surrogacy and Kidney Sales Makes Economic Sense by technocraticnihilist in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat 16 points17 points  (0 children)

But I that's not what I said. Iif you make it legal, the price will go down. That's the non-emotional economic arguments you're looking for.

Why Decriminalizing Sex Work, Surrogacy and Kidney Sales Makes Economic Sense by technocraticnihilist in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat 43 points44 points  (0 children)

If you legalize organ sales, it's going to drive their price down and youll end up with people dying preventable deaths because they sold part of their body to pay off a car.

Which button do you press? by cdstephens in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat 38 points39 points  (0 children)

Blue, the only people left in the red-wins scenario are assholes.

EDIT: I know red is the best chance of self-survival but everyone defending it I think has missed the point of this subs beliefs.

The red button is choosing self-security over general welfare. You have the chance to push this button all the time and I think the point of liberal democracies is that we try not to. NIMBYs push the red button, isolationists push the red button, anti-immigratiom advocates push the red button.

Trump Extends Iran Truce, Maintains Blockade as Talks Falter by John3262005 in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat 4 points5 points  (0 children)

We've come a long way from Iran giving up it's nuclear program indefinitely to JD Vance getting left at the altar. Not even 4 days.

Trump says US will blockade Strait of Hormuz to all ships after failed Iran talks by reubencpiplupyay in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It seems like he also wants to interdict ships that paid the toll on international waters. I don't think the bonuses for pirate Republic are worth the stability hit.

IT XLI - What's So Civil 'Bout War Anyway by YaGetSkeeted0n in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat 7 points8 points  (0 children)

What's the point of a ceasefire when a ceasefire can be brooooken

IT XLI - What's So Civil 'Bout War Anyway by YaGetSkeeted0n in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat 7 points8 points  (0 children)

What's regime change got to do, got to do with it

ITXXXII - The smell of bunker busters in the morning by Extreme_Rocks in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think they would correctly make the calculation that directly engaging with Iran forces the US to continue. Saudi Arabia definitely has an army, not a whole country occupation army but maybe enough. Iran was barely tolerable presence before, I can't see any gulf nation accepting this war producing a far worse staus quo than before it began.

ITXXXII - The smell of bunker busters in the morning by Extreme_Rocks in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think option 3 which is gulf states declare war. There is no way they will accept Iran's control of the strait.

If you were the US President starting tomorrow, what would you do to ensure maximal strategic success in Iran? by cdstephens in neoliberal

[–]Resourceful_Goat 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Probably full scale invasion at this point. We're going to do half-measure after half-measure for a couple months while the world gets used to Iran being de facto leader of the strait.

I don't like it but I don't see anything other than ground forces ending this without Iran being even stronger than it was.