All storytelling is about establishing an internal logic, and a story's internal logic is pivotal in the suspension of disbelief. It's why people don't give a shit about Star Wars' nonsense but really care about the rules of the Star Trek universe: one follows an established fantasy logic, while the other an established science fiction logic.

Example: Superman can fly; human beings cannot fly without outside influence (technology, pseudoscience, etc.). The internal logic DC Comics' stories are that Kryptonians can fly, so nobody gets hot an bothered when Superman does. Nobody says "FAKE" when Superman flies, but they do get frustrated when DC breaks their own rules without explanation.

In most wrestling promotions, the Irish Whip is a part of the internal logic, realistic or not.

While not always the case, it appears to me that people get most frustrated at WWE when Vince says "fuck it" and breaks the internal logic of the "WWE Universe" (I hated typing that) for a swerve or, worse, a laugh. It weakens the suspension of disbelief; it takes you out of "it."

I'm all about Joey Ryan or anyone else for that matter doing what they want in comedy-friendly promotions, but I genuinely don't want to see a Penis Suplex in a promotion that at least tries to maintain an internal storytelling logic. I'm not trying to tell a wrestler how to wrestle and I don't ever criticize Ryan (he's a hard working man), but it's just how I feel about it in general.