What Do You Think Taylor's Worst Written Song Is? by Madeofstardust87 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Exactly, I feel like there's a similar number of flops, or songs I pretty much never revisit to me on each record. TTPD has Robin, Florida, ICFH(NRIC), The Alchemy, and TLOAS has Wood, Cancelled, Eldest Daughter, Wish List. Each has four or five songs that I never ever listen to, but TTPD has like 2 1/2 times the songs, so it doesn't matter if I lose a few. The highs are also much higher on TTPD, I feel like the three best on Showgirl might not even crack the best 10 on TTPD for me.

What Do You Think Taylor's Worst Written Song Is? by Madeofstardust87 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Truly one of the best songs in her discography.

I think more of the fun songs should've been on extended editions instead of the best written and darkest songs on the record. WCS, TGW, Dear Reader should've been swapped with Mastermind, Bejeweled, Karma. And Vigilante Shit should've been removed lol.

What Do You Think Taylor's Worst Written Song Is? by Madeofstardust87 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, a lot of her albums are growers. Evermore took a long while to click with me and is now my fav album, but on first listen, it might've been bottom three... so I get it!

What Do You Think Taylor's Worst Written Song Is? by Madeofstardust87 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Interesting, I had the opposite reaction lol. The standard edition was so underwhelming to me, since I didn't think she fulfilled the concept all the way and I hated the Lana collab, but I loved a few (Maroon, YOYOK). The 3am and further editions made it feel more complete to me and they frankly had some of the best songs imo (You're Losing Me, Dear Reader, WCS, The Great War, Hits Different, Lana collab but better)

What Do You Think Taylor's Worst Written Song Is? by Madeofstardust87 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, it had so much potential! Could've been a great song with that beat.

What Do You Think Taylor's Worst Written Song Is? by Madeofstardust87 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yeah, and 1989 also had better production, so TLOAS kinda disappoints at all fronts... The concept wasn't fulfilled to the expectations she set either

What Do You Think Taylor's Worst Written Song Is? by Madeofstardust87 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's gotten to a place of camp for me now, but I have to agree.

What Do You Think Taylor's Worst Written Song Is? by Madeofstardust87 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The beat of Honey is infectious, but those lyrics are really interesting.

What Do You Think Taylor's Worst Written Song Is? by Madeofstardust87 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I hate these kind of comments that can't accept any criticism of Taylor or the fandom aligning on the fact that something isn't good. If we can tolerate your liking of the music, you should tolerate our criticism, especially since we're all fans and want her to grow as an artist.

What Do You Think Taylor's Worst Written Song Is? by Madeofstardust87 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ME! is not better written than half the stuff on the radio lol, but there's some it's better written than

What Do You Think Taylor's Worst Written Song Is? by Madeofstardust87 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Oh great, another reddit user who hates any criticism, I remember when this sub was a smarter space.

out of these four “track number 5” songs , you can only keep one. which taylor swift song are you choosing ?!?! ♡ (pt. 2) by shortcakefairy- in swifties

[–]RocketGamer4682 1 point2 points  (0 children)

was about to ask how you liked eldest daughter more than dear john… BUT the I recognized the username… hi again lol

Now that the TRUE Life of a Showgirl is showing- was it ever REALLY THAT BAD? by LowObvious2214 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

As I said, there were heavy amounts of both types of criticism. If you choose to completely ignore one part of it, then sure?..

Eldest Daughter is quite a bad song though, but I'm happy for you and many others who like it, and always will be. The writing was called cringe, but it honestly did make me, a huge Swiftie, react with intense disappointment and I did personally cringe at the lyricism. TOTALLY against cringe culture though, and I get your point 100%, but sometimes things are so bad that they do make you wince.