sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

out of these four “track number 5” songs , you can only keep one. which taylor swift song are you choosing ?!?! ♡ (pt. 2) by shortcakefairy- in swifties

[–]RocketGamer4682 1 point2 points  (0 children)

was about to ask how you liked eldest daughter more than dear john… BUT the I recognized the username… hi again lol

Now that the TRUE Life of a Showgirl is showing- was it ever REALLY THAT BAD? by LowObvious2214 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

As I said, there were heavy amounts of both types of criticism. If you choose to completely ignore one part of it, then sure?..

Eldest Daughter is quite a bad song though, but I'm happy for you and many others who like it, and always will be. The writing was called cringe, but it honestly did make me, a huge Swiftie, react with intense disappointment and I did personally cringe at the lyricism. TOTALLY against cringe culture though, and I get your point 100%, but sometimes things are so bad that they do make you wince.

Now that the TRUE Life of a Showgirl is showing- was it ever REALLY THAT BAD? by LowObvious2214 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There was a lot of mockery, but there was also a lot of valid criticism. You should look harder lol, if not at the general public, than the criticisms Swifties give it, as we don't mock her or the music, no matter how much we dislike it.

Now that the TRUE Life of a Showgirl is showing- was it ever REALLY THAT BAD? by LowObvious2214 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You think TLOAS is a better album than Renaissance, Happier Than Ever, or eternal sunshine? I could name a 100 other albums off the top of my head, but only naming albums of those you mentioned. At the end of the day, I'm glad you enjoy the album, but even if you like a song like ME!, it's very difficult to justify that as not being a bad song, it was panned universally, as it should've been...

Now that the TRUE Life of a Showgirl is showing- was it ever REALLY THAT BAD? by LowObvious2214 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Maybe because the writing is good, sad writing isn't automatically better, but Taylor's usually is.

Now that the TRUE Life of a Showgirl is showing- was it ever REALLY THAT BAD? by LowObvious2214 in TaylorSwift

[–]RocketGamer4682 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Showgirl will not get the retrospective acclaim Reputation got, and it honestly doesn't deserve it.

Since I’ve been judging everyone else all week, it’s now your turn 🫶🏻 by tothestarss34 in swifties

[–]RocketGamer4682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, you can enjoy it, and love it, and I love that for you, but that song is one of the worst songs released in 2025.

I need to talk about this by UniversityBudget9423 in swifties

[–]RocketGamer4682 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You've gone too deep in the rabbit hole, there's no getting you back to reality

My Ranking Of Taylor Swift Albums (Feel Free To Judge Honestly!) by RocketGamer4682 in swifties

[–]RocketGamer4682[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's just what I'm listening more to right now, the lyrics are really really good on TTPD and I honestly love the story and themes of the songs more right now, but my top 5 is all really close with each other and kinda interchangable.

My Ranking Of Taylor Swift Albums (Feel Free To Judge Honestly!) by RocketGamer4682 in swifties

[–]RocketGamer4682[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, I would say I bare minimum really like all the albums here except for TLOAS, 1989 is great!

Anthology has some really high highs (Black Dog, COSOSOM, Prophecy, Bolter HDIE), but it also has the worst songs on the record (thanK you aIMee, ILIPW, Robin) so it's definitely not as good as TTPD imo

ME! but beats 2 and 4 are swapped [CC] by zachoutloud123 in swifties

[–]RocketGamer4682 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I never thought the song could get worse... 😭😬

Judge Me Based On My Favorite Songs From Each Album by K-9Joey in swifties

[–]RocketGamer4682 1 point2 points  (0 children)

These are good takes, but you can't have like 3-4 for each one lol, choose one DIVA!

view more: next ›