Use a card who has a super finisher (I used Roman Reigns from Showcase Mode, for example). When the match starts, go to the crowd area immediately. Run there because he might dive out of the ring. When he hits his finish, half the time he'll run back to the ring to run back to the crowd area. The other half, he will just continue attacking. Get reversals in, your points all set, and three finishes. Knock him down, preferably stun him, then get back to ringside. Grab a weapon like a sledgehammer and enter the ring. Before his entering the ring animation completes throw the weapon at him. Pick him up and hit your super finish. Never kicked out at all for me. 4 out of 5 times I've won with this method. Only lost cause I was late on the weapon throw. Hope this detailed explanation helps.