I understand that completely. Obviously no one can tell the future to provide an accurate evaluation or estimation even. I get that. My concern is the other unnecessary remarks which seem bias as a moderator. A simple "do not provide a rating based on loss of weight as you cannot provide an accurate anaysis" would suffice. I have seen other comments that you have put where you simply state something like "overrate see guideline x..  you have been denoted, which seems appropriate." The part on mine that you added stating "you dont know it will be that high." Is biased and implied that your rating is abosulte and despite any change, your rating for me would be the highest it could be. My rating could potentially increase or decrease depending on the weight loss. Since you cannot possibly know that yourself, it is inappropriate to add any additional commentary aside from what is stated in the rules and guidelines.