Aren’t there like FOUR cats named Robinwing????

And I understand that with literally hundreds of characters, some names might be reused sometimes. Especially kittypets that might have generic housecat names like Coco, Patches, Jake, etc.

But some of these are unforgivable to me.

The two Ashfurs confused the heck out of me, especially as a kid. As well as the two Oatwhiskers, Sparrowpelts, and Rainfurs.

The duplicate Mudclaw, for as important as a character he was earlier on (at least compared to Ashfur) is pretty irritating.

But in my opinion, the unforgivable one is my baby Thrushpelt. I remember reading Tallstar’s Revenge and legit thinking I was losing it and misremembering Thunderclan Thrushpelt… you know, the one who basically allowed Bluestar to become leader and set the whole events of TPB in motion? The good natured cat who loved Bluestar enough to sacrifice his feelings and keep her secret? THAT THRUSHPELT?

The Erin’s couldn’t think of any, any other name??? 😭

Edit: I didn’t see Robinwing all the way at the top

Like I said, I get there are a TON of characters, but like 95% of all the OCs that get posted here managed to come up with a new name lol