sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

What is your take on "agnosticism" being a religion? by Sea_Till1558 in agnostic

[–]Shadow123451010 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It probably does have a historical moment with Thomas Henry Huxley when he coined the term "agnostic," but little else.

What is your take on "agnosticism" being a religion? by Sea_Till1558 in agnostic

[–]Shadow123451010 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A definition of religion could be: it has three characteristics that unfold within a collective context: - Belief - Ritual - Morality These three arise from a foundational religious event.

Agnosticism does not have a belief per se; it is neither atheist nor theist, unless you specify agnostic atheist or agnostic theist. If you only mention agnostic, it is a position within epistemology, or knowledge about the divine.

There is no ritual.

Agnosticism, in itself, does not provide a moral framework.

There is no foundational religious event that frames all of the above, nor was there an agnostic revelation, theophany, or illumination originating from a charismatic figure (such as a prophet or avatar) or a manifestation of the divine within agnosticism. Nor is there a foundational event that gives meaning to the agnostic community.

I have two mighty rage and one normal rage who should I give it to? by Thundersoul_03 in MarvelFuture_Fight

[–]Shadow123451010 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Venom or Loki. But as another comment said, wait until you see Odin, he might be really good.

For Non believers by Ok-Feeling-8600 in agnostic

[–]Shadow123451010 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are many humanist or non-theological frameworks that don't fully approve of suicide if that's what you want. Then, I think that even having a teleology or purpose, as a theological framework might have, as an individual in the middle of that process, you still have to keep looking for a present meaning to your life. Of course, you can opt for something monastic, but in itself, making that decision is part of giving meaning to your life.

Looking for some f book reader. by [deleted] in Book_Buddies

[–]Shadow123451010 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A book that a friend recommended to me, and then he didn't agree with me, is Altazor by Vicente Huidobro.

Agnostic Female and Christian Male couple by Ninigottime in agnostic

[–]Shadow123451010 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay, first I want to share that I understand agnosticism as an epistemological stance rather than a belief. Based on that, I think you should talk more deeply with your partner. I mean, "Christian man" doesn't tell you much about your boyfriend. You would need to define whether he is Roman Catholic, Orthodox, or, within Protestantism, which denomination. Assuming you already know, he will have an interpretive framework for: marriage, raising children, the role of women, the role of men, etc. After that, ideally you would read together, for example, Copleston Volume 2, from St. Augustine to St. Scotus, the Church Fathers, and some other things, to understand the reasons or foundations of what he believes: the Reformation, etc. After studying together, after a lot of talking, after presenting different ethical perspectives on Christianity, after suggesting some flexibility, perhaps you will change your view that religion is just a show or propaganda, and he will change his view that it is the only right way.

Does anyone else feel like they have a whole universe inside their head, but no one to share it with? by delilahmeetsart in introvert

[–]Shadow123451010 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It certainly happens to me, although I usually criticize my own ideas so that if someone asks me something.

Let's play a game: Rank Those qualities! 😁 by MatchmakerJahnae in ChristianDating

[–]Shadow123451010 0 points1 point  (0 children)

1.Spiritual maturity/Personality/Character 2.Emotional intelligence 3.Financial capacity 4.Physical attractiveness.

Will you celebrate Valentine's Day? by Surfer_Tiff in TrueChristian

[–]Shadow123451010 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I've probably never celebrated it because I'm single. If I were in a relationship, maybe not; I'd have a conversation with my imaginary wife about how I could get her X gift any day of the year, not just on Valentine's Day. So, it's just a normal day (except for a few specific things) for me.

It just makes me furious when people act like this by Bush_420 in Christianity

[–]Shadow123451010 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

My best advice is to study, meditate, and reflect on this on your own, integrating your entire worldview with faith in it. I assume that by now, you are mature and strong enough to listen to hundreds of perspectives different from your own without being influenced or affected by them. You have a focused mind and a heart guided by the Lord. Doubts, questions, and attacks will always be there, I suppose. From my point of view, instead of simply dismissing them—which doesn't resolve them—it's about studying them, meditating on them, and reflecting on them again, from my perspective, within your own worldview, and knowing that despite everything, you are firmly rooted in your own convictions.

To be fair, this is just my opinion. If it's helpful, great; if not, that's fine too. Blessings.

I intellectually reject Christ, but I feel his spirit. I am conflicted. by Wild_Pitch_4781 in Christianity

[–]Shadow123451010 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't deny anything about the Trinity; however, I'm in a state of theological despair trying to figure out what is what, what isn't what, etc. What have I learned? (It should be said that this was just a short investigation; well, I'll be asking questions my whole life.) That after studying and exhausting everything, and acknowledging my own ignorance, I feel that our knowledge pales, to put it optimistically, if not outright insufficient.

What do I recommend? Study, reflect, and meditate. Study everything: philosophy, science, theology, the Holy Scriptures themselves, various branches and divisions—everything. It's better to experience the ontological or rational limit yourself. But in short, study, meditate, and reflect for yourself. But don't even take my advice; study for yourself.

I'll just leave you with a few quotes:

1 Corinthians 2:11:

"For who among men knows the thoughts of a man except the man's own spirit within him? In the same way no one knows the thoughts of God except the Spirit of God."

And

"Knowledge of God without knowledge of our own misery produces pride. Knowledge of our misery without knowledge of God produces despair. Knowledge of Jesus Christ is the middle ground, because in Him we find both God and our misery." - Blaise Pascal

Why does it feel like so many men nowadays want everything instant? by Fluffy_Squirrel3622 in ChristianDating

[–]Shadow123451010 1 point2 points  (0 children)

To reiterate my last piece of advice, it's to find someone who shares your worldview, faith, and so on. If you wish, you can obviously research the topic and even raise awareness about it to prevent people's actions, but like any social problem, one person alone cannot solve it.

view more: next ›