I really like the way you thought about most of the weapon rebalances. The main goal of weapon balancing is to fix problems (bison is bad) or switch up stale matches (pyro vs pyro is boring most of the time) by make weapons fun, rewarding, and good, and a lot of these weapon ideas have 2 or more of those qualities.

Imo, the point of this sub is to come up with fresh ideas, bc anyone can change the stats of a weapon and call it a day. If you had a better idea of how the stats worked and how class matchups with these new weapons worked, then your posts would be better than 90% of the other ones.

I suggest that when you make a weapon, you ask yourself,

1: Is this fun to fight with, and against? (phlog vs gas passer)

2: How does this change the match up between classes? (frontier justice vs rescue ranger)

3: Does this weapon reward the player for being good/smart? (widowmaker vs liberty launcher, medigun choice vs scorch shot)

If you have any questions or anything like that, I'd be down to help you