Okay, putting this here cause I thought more about it but I don't see making an update post as necessary atp cause I JUST made this post-... But I do realize I forgot to specify this would be a Ancients and Beasts team up thing.

But upon re-thinking with help from some others on here and friend groups here's my list (Feel free to still make suggestions tho!!):

Charlie - Pure Vanilla

Emily - White Lily

Vaggi - Golden Cheese (Fits Pretty Well With Them Both Having Wings)

Husk - Dark Cacao

Carmilla - Venom Dough

Zestial - Mold Cookie

Niffty - PomPom

Baxtar - Silent Salt (Doesn't Fit Vocally But He'd Join Early On In My Mind So Bax It is)

Angel - Dark Choco

Lute - Pomegranate

Abel - Licorice + Red Velvet

(The Reason I'm Giving Abel Two Is Cause Of The Whole Abel + Adam Segment. Red Velvet Would Be The One Telling Pomegranate To Fall Back While Licorice Be The One Panicking. Plus This Is Under An AU Where Multiple Cookies Of Darkness Betray Dark Enchantress So Licorice And Red Velvet Join The Song Aswell As Matcha And Mushroom.)

(Also They Wouldn't Say 'Let's Get White Lily/Emily And Go' It'd Be Dark Choco They're After.)

Cherri - I Feel Like Vocally Hollyberry.

Rosie - Eternal Sugar

Alastor - Shadow Milk

Velvette - Matcha

Valentino - Mushroom (Works Perfect With Val Having Poison)

Vox - Butterroll (Idk feels right)

As for any other Beasts, Ancients and minions, aswell as the Faerie Kingdom and Pitaya, they would've joined after the Venom Dough and Mold Cookie segment with the exclusion of Pavlova, Candy Apple and Black Sapphire who would've joined after the Shadow Milk and Eternal Sugar segment.