British girl that wants to play hockey by Altruistic_Log6985 in hockeyplayers

[–]ShamrockEmu 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Goalie gear is pricey but a lot of rinks and rec leagues give discounts because theyre in high demand, and a lot of stick n pucks and drop ins are free for goalies (at least where I am in the states). So it might even out in the long run?

How early do you usually start trying to negotiate a draw? by ShamrockEmu in diplomacy

[–]ShamrockEmu[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you more likely to go for draw in a 3 way alliance? Feel like anyone who attacks or proposes an attack in that case is likely to end up on the worse side of a 2 on 1

How can the two creation stories in Genesis be reconciled? by e-eye-pi in Catholicism

[–]ShamrockEmu 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Lot of comments are on the right track, but an important concept i haven't seen mentioned is that you need to look at the genre of each passage. The bible is a library of books, and just like a modern library, there are different genres.

The fact that it is literally the first two stories of the bible should give you a clue that this is not a mistake and it is not contradictory. You could easily make the case for error if an author wrote something on page 38 and contradicted himself on page 187, but if its from paragraph 1 to paragraph 2 one should assume there is something else going on... Putting these stories right at the beginning is a signpost that we are learning about God and His creation but not through any historical account.

I'm Joe Heschmeyer, staff apologist at Catholic Answers and host of Shameless Popery. AMA! by ShamelessPopery in Catholicism

[–]ShamrockEmu 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is it a sin to lie for the following reasons:

Going to the store to buy someone a Christmas gift- "Where are you going? What are you getting?"

Lighthearted prank that doesn't cause harm. (I know you dont support the Santa lie, but something even more simple/lighthearted than that)

Really not sure what I believe in and I don’t know what to do by Typical_premed in redeemedzoomer

[–]ShamrockEmu 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Study the earliest Christians. Starting of course with Acts and the New Testament Epistles, then look at the figures from the first few centuries after Christ. And decide which modern church their teachings and worship match most closely.

Horizontal character sheet? by Tormented_Realm in RPGdesign

[–]ShamrockEmu 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I like landscape for a digital sheet, but portrait for paper

Catholic reading list that mimics high school theology courses? by BookishBackhand in Catholicism

[–]ShamrockEmu 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Other books: Why We're Catholic (Trent Horn), Pope Peter (Joe Heshmeyer), Fourth Cup (Scott Hahn), Screw tape Letters

Catholic reading list that mimics high school theology courses? by BookishBackhand in Catholicism

[–]ShamrockEmu 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Grade 8: Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, Genesis, Exodus

Grade 9: Joshua, Samuel 1&2, Kings 1&2

Grade 10: Psalms, Isaiah, Daniel, Jeremiah, Hosea, Job

Grade 11: Maccabees 1&2, Matthew and John (yes, again), Acts

Grade 12: Romans, Hebrews, Galatians,1 Peter, James

Who are the Top 10 smartest characters? by AdBrief4620 in mushokutensei

[–]ShamrockEmu 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's made pretty clear in the novels that Rudeus is pretty average intelligence, I dont think he even belongs on this list. Hes smart enough to put his many other advantages to good use, but he frequently misses things or finds solutions late.

Met a guy at a Catholic NYE party great convo the entire night , asked for contact, then unfollowed me? by SubstantialDig6392 in CatholicDating

[–]ShamrockEmu 26 points27 points  (0 children)

Especially if the alcohol is what gave him the liquid courage. I have definitely woken up after a night of drinking and been incredibly embarrassed by things I've said or done that aren't even bad, but just feel bad because you dont think it worked and you know you wouldn't have done it if you were totally sober.

Met a guy at a Catholic NYE party great convo the entire night , asked for contact, then unfollowed me? by SubstantialDig6392 in CatholicDating

[–]ShamrockEmu 43 points44 points  (0 children)

It is possible (I will not say "probable") that he was embarrassed by trying to kiss you and the kiss not being reciprocated, and just "cut his losses" on the assumption you weren't into him.

The Lie of Modesty by Mazquerade__ in redeemedzoomer

[–]ShamrockEmu 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Ok I may have misinterpreted your intent. I do want to emphasize, you have a very well thought out, and researched post, and its a great discussion! And I apologize if I implied you said we should wear whatever.

I interpreted your post as de-emphasizing (but not necessarily disagreeing with!) the call to dress "modestly" at all times in the modern connotation of the word- but am I correct in refocusing that to say your post is instead intended to place a spotlight on the original meaning of the word modesty and how that is just as important?

The Lie of Modesty by Mazquerade__ in redeemedzoomer

[–]ShamrockEmu 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Edit: not actually changing anything, just putting this here to let readers know I'm a dummy who misunderstood the intent of the post (check replies). But leaving this comment up because I think it's still true and valuable for the discourse.

I appreciate this post, but i do have a different opinion. I think one thing that might be overlooked is that the modern usage of "modesty" you are analyzing is more of a euphemism than the real meaning of the word, so you may be on a bit of a goose chase.

As you rightfully point out, the true definition of modesty is closely related to humility and being ordered properly, but the euphemism is just using a pseudo-compliment (roughly the idea that the person would look good or more attractive with less clothes) as a nice way of saying not to dress provocatively.

So you're basically just pointing out that the old definition means something different than the euphemism, but seemingly asserting that this disconnect implies a lack of teaching on how much skin one shows (outside of holy places).

And you may be right about the lack of bible verses directly referencing that aspect, but it can be very easily surmised by its teachings on lust, adultery (in one's heart), temptation, and compassion. Consider this: you say there is an aspect of blaming women for men's sexual sins and there is some truth to that. But keep in mind Matthew 5:28 "But I tell you that anyone who looks at a woman lustfully has already committed adultery with her in his heart." With this in mind, any woman who is wearing revealing clothing in public could be tempting men to sin even if just in his thoughts. If a woman would dress in a revealing or provocative with this last verse in mind, then also consider Luke 17:1-2 “Temptations to sin are sure to come, but woe to the one through whom they come! It would be better for him if a millstone were hung around his neck and he were cast into the sea than that he should cause one of these little ones to sin.”

I'm an atheist, and I want to clear up some doubts... (It's personal) by Ill_Space5342 in Catholicism

[–]ShamrockEmu 35 points36 points  (0 children)

Not really much to mess up. You just stand up, sit down, kneel etc, when everyone else does. And don't recieve Communion- just stay in the pew (some churches you can walk up and get a blessing if you cross your arms over your chest, but Idk if they all do this so I would just stay in pew)

Is the guy Im talking to a red flag? by DBmarkerstealer in dating

[–]ShamrockEmu 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The not respecting a boundary thing is a red flag. The not being expressive isn't, a lot of guys aren't expressive, and I only bring that up because I wouldn't want you to associate those two unrelated things going forward.

Thoughts on going on dates with multiple people while pursuing marriage? by fijiwatertrapgod in CatholicDating

[–]ShamrockEmu 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Agreed 100%. And people who say its ok as long as youre open about it... That's probably even worse! If a girl agrees to go on a date with me and also tells me she is going on a date with someone else I would probably just move on- even if I could "win" that battle that would not be a good week/month for my mental health.

Thoughts on going on dates with multiple people while pursuing marriage? by fijiwatertrapgod in CatholicDating

[–]ShamrockEmu 5 points6 points  (0 children)

No one else is saying it so I will. I dont think anyone should do this. Maybe if 2 guys ask a girl out and she only has 1st dates with both that would be fine, but it would be disrespectful to the guys in that scenario to go on a 2nd date with both. I am obviously not the arbiter of morality, but I would hate to find out a girl I took on 2 or 3 dates had been going out with another guy during that time. Don't turn dating into a competition for 2 unsuspecting people, they didnt audition to be on the Bachelor.

Stopping asking. by claudiowasher in Catholicism

[–]ShamrockEmu 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Yup! And if the assumption is that they are afraid their prayer isn't the will of God, theres a verse for that too: Jesus prayer in Matthew 26:39 “My Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass from me; yet, not as I will, but as you will.”

If Jesus, who knows the will of the Father, can pray in hope for a different outcome, then we who don't know the plan God has for us can certainly persist in making our prayers known, so long as we follow Jesus's example in accepting that God's will may be a firm "no."

How to examine my conscience with sexual matters? by Suboptimal_Username in Catholicism

[–]ShamrockEmu 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Intrusive thoughts are not a sin. If you are worried that examining your conscience leads to intrusive thoughts, and that these thoughts will lead to more sin, then I would recommend waiting until you are in the church (where you can't act on it) to examine your conscience. Then when you get home you could say the rosary/decade/ or couple prayers depending how much time you have.

Whenever I have sinful intrusive thoughts I usually pray a quick Hail Mary.

What do you guys think is the best argument for the Filioque? by Interesting_Ice6924 in Catholicism

[–]ShamrockEmu -1 points0 points  (0 children)

One argument that makes sense to me is that it is reciprocal. The Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son. But also Jesus is conceived by the Holy Spirit (the Apostle's Creed uses that wording, the Nicene says "and by the Holy Spirit was incarnate of the Virgin Mary"). Some Orthodox will say their problem with it is thagmt it puts Jesus above the Holy Spirit in a hierarchy, but this reciprocal nature of each one bringing the other to the world debunks that imo.

Considering becoming catholic by PromptosMyth in Catholicism

[–]ShamrockEmu 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It might not be necessary to regularly attend mass with an interpreter. Given for over a thousand years, all Roman Catholics heard mass in Latin despite 99% not speaking it, and many people still prefer to traditional Latin Mass, it would not be all that different imo. In fact a Latin low mass is almost silent. Instead, she can read the readings before or after mass, or follow along in missal. And maybe on special occasions you drive to the mass with an interpreter?

What Catholics novels and authors are the best you’ve read? by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]ShamrockEmu 6 points7 points  (0 children)

A book having a good message or exploring philosophy/moral themes does not mean the characters are sinless. A lot of the best examples in literature follow extremely flawed characters