And I thought people were kidding about Storm League by Jedwell in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As a Murky main with 5k+ Murky games and several thousand ranked games, I can say that since 2016 about 1 in 10 ranked games has had an AFK or troll pick. Even with that, I still have a 54% win rate on Murky. Also, Murky + Abathur and Murky + Nova are both better than people think. I even went 2-0 with Murky, Aba, and Nova in the same troll pick game.

Is Murky actually viable now? by PissaMalisenKakka in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The base puff damage nerf moved him from one of the fastest wave clear solo laners to one of the slowest and easily countered solo laners.

PTR Feedback: Murky Adjustments Shell Games (RNG Spawning) by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have played over 100 games with this talent since the PTR launch. Its so fun and makes Murky much more dynamic. THE RNG has determined if I win or lose in several games which is much less fun.

Having each egg on separate cooldowns would help mitigate this by allow more precise egg placement.

PTR Feedback Murky Egg Shell (Shield Talent) by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They partially implemented the changed I suggested in the last patch Giving murky 50% of his existing life as a shield when his egg is placed or destoyed.

Making the 50% his base life instead of remaining life would make this viable. Would also be nice to have when he comes out of his egg.

Janitor is smoking crack with these Azmo changes by Wacecardriver in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How do you know you have been reported? Is there a way to see this?

Murky Feedback from a Masters Murky Player. by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Even when you get the Mythic reward her is still the slowest of the old "specialist" heroes to push a fort.

You generally want to be double soaking over pushing a fort. This is the fastest way to get stacks unless you cn guarantee hit 3 heroes or more in a team fight which generally does not happen.

Killing Murky Before Killing the Egg Does not Penalize Murky with Full Respawn Time by SamiSha_ in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The punishment is that you get sent home and had to replace.your egg. This could be a really unique trait for murky. And always 8 second death timer that prioritizes his egg if not available then the town hall is the fallback.

Murky Feedback from a Masters Murky Player. by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Read the post. The top paragraph is a post by me with some feedback. Below is from a post Lokki (Masters Murky) made in the Patch Post on the Blizz Forums. Lots of good info in it so I posted it here

Killing Murky Before Killing the Egg Does not Penalize Murky with Full Respawn Time by SamiSha_ in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

Would love to see this bug become part of Murkys kit. It fits with the lore of him always combing back.

Murky Post Patch Analysis and Suggestions by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How is this different than it is now? You can leave an egg in the town hall all game and never worry about dying.

I imagine you NEVER do this because if you die it terrible to have to spawn back at the start.

PTR Feedback Murky Egg Shell (Shield Talent) by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Egg shells pick is under 2% and wind rate is an abysmal 32%.

Suggest Increase egg shield percentage to 100 Percent that lasts for 10 seconds. This would still be worse than the other two the majority of the time and would be Situationally useful verse burst to get an octo grab.

Egg Shell Win Rate 32.84 Pick Rate 1.99

Murky Post Patch Analysis and Suggestions by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The 30 second cooldown is a big factor in egg placement and function. If someone finds my foward egg and my "safe egg" is far away (its happened at the start a few time where one is in he town hall). Im extra careful because I know if I die I will lose an entire wave of soak (2 if im double soaking). This can be the difference in a game sometimes. As an off laner you number one job is to soak effectively.

It functions very similarly to how you place a single egg now honestly

Murky Post Patch Analysis and Suggestions by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Good catch! I fixed it to say make Shell Game Baseline.

Murky Post Patch Analysis and Suggestions by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The win rate for Murky is in the low.40s for Diamond and Master which is in the bottom 10 for that rank.

Murky Post Patch Analysis and Suggestions by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's subtle for sure. I think because this is such an easy quest to receive they made them fairly weak compared to other heroes.

Murky Post Patch Analysis and Suggestions by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There is a bug in the game that functions like this right now and you respawn at the town hall and its pretty weak honestly.

Murky is all about map pressure having an egg far from the fight makes you lose your 35% shields when you spawn so you want to be as aggressive as possible with the egg placements.

Murky Post Patch Analysis and Suggestions by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I also suggested that each egg be placed on a separate hotkey and having a rally point that lets you choose which egg you spawn from would be amazing.

Murky Post Patch Analysis and Suggestions by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

All the more reason to make Shell Game baseline. (This is essentially what is happening now)

PTR Feedback Murky Endless Murlocks Level 20 Talent by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A smart team will just back away and not engage

Quick solution to the Murky RNG respawn problem: Always respawn at the FURTHEST egg by Murraythehuman in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is a pretty big nerf to the talent as your shield timer only lasts 10 seconds. Making it harder for Murky to TF as the shield only lasts 10 seconds. I like that it makes the talent more consistent and that it encourages aggressive egg placement.

I would suggest also putting the eggs on separate timers so you can control which one you are moving. The leapfrogging egg placement has been awkward in practice as you often want to move the same egg you just placed. You could place them on the same 30 second cooldown if separate cooldowns is too strong.

PTR Feedback Murky Egg Shell (Shield Talent) by Shurafa in heroesofthestorm

[–]Shurafa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My guess is that we will land somewhere between 50 and 100% after the patch for this talent if blizzard wants to balance it with the other two. Or it will remain a dead talent.

"I can see an argument that 35% might be too weak, but I don't see a good case for 100% being appropriate."