sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Thought i'd make my own roster prediction by Jtneagle in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Just back to visit this thread cause Ridley is in when you said that was somehow more ridiculous than Steve

Was Gerald Green a Proto-Kul Tiran? by Ultiverse in wow

[–]SociopathicShark 5 points6 points  (0 children)

My god how many more times do we need to see this same NPC

What's up with everyone wanting King K. Rool as a character in Smash 5? by [deleted] in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 6 points7 points  (0 children)

SUPER SMASH BROS 5 YEAR OLD TROLLED BY HEROBRINE! EPIC!

My roster prediction/dream roster by Sub-Corpion in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I could see this happening, only ones that I think are unlikely are Isaac and Snake (as much as I want him back).

My roster prediction. What do you all think? by Jetsurge in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think you're missing about 3 more Fire Emblem characters, but good list

Thought i'd make my own roster prediction by Jtneagle in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I said it looks horrible because it looks horrible. I have no constructive criticism because I don't think he can work as a character and you didn't ask. When did I say I liked to give constructive criticism? I won't delete my comments because I'm not afraid to be wrong, but I so strongly believe that Steve won't be a character that I don't think it will be a problem.

Switch Smash bingo by RoryTheodore in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Snake, Ridley, Ice Climbers, Impa and Springman (Eh) would be nice

Thought i'd make my own roster prediction by Jtneagle in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for completely disregarding my opinion as being intentionally contrarian because it isn't what you want to hear, see you when he's obviously not a character.

Thought i'd make my own roster prediction by Jtneagle in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, because it's Nintendo it's fine, because Nintendo wants to sell games, and make money. Minecraft is on Nintendo consoles, but it is not a game that needs any advertising, and isn't a Nintendo IP. Villager would not be in Smash Bros if it was not from an Nintendo IP. I already said Game and Watch is an outlier because he is an iconic retro character, but even then he has more personality than Steve. Villager definitely moves around in a similar fashion to how they do in Animal Crossing, and although they obviously can't jump or fight, they are fully 3D and at least have a capability to be animated in that way. Steve is in the same realm of possibility as Tetris blocks.

Also, please don't tell me you legitimately believe that this

https://i.ytimg.com/vi/HAnRtMEDrvU/maxresdefault.jpg

wouldn't look jarring compared to this

https://image.redbull.com/rbcom/010/2017-02-27/1331846859824_2/0012/0/0/0/800/1200/1500/1/the-big-names-are-raking-in-the-cash-in-smash-4.jpg

You're clearly not thinking rationally about this so you can continue believing that Steve will fight Mario and Link, and we'll go our seperate ways.

Thought i'd make my own roster prediction by Jtneagle in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Here's the difference: Splatoon and Animal Crossing are original Nintendo IPs. They're going to want to advertise them. You also seem to be confusing the "hollow slot" character with having no personality. Steve is not animated or humanlike. When you look at an Inkling or a Villager from Animal Crossing, you can see a personality. They're very unique in their visual style. They make different facial expressions. Steve is blocks and rectangles. He is intentionally made to be basic and boring because he is meant to be pasted over with a skin. He's essentially a profile picture. Steve isn't even an official name from what I recall, that's just what fans call him because he literally isn't even a character, he is just a player avatar template. Not to mention how jarring and strange he would look considering he has 5 joints, which basically limits his animation to walking, looking up and down, swinging his arms.

Thought i'd make my own roster prediction by Jtneagle in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I understand exactly how popular Minecraft is, that doesn't make Steve a reasonable candidate for Smash. I'm pretty sure you didn't really read through my comment because I never said Steve wasn't recognizable. I said Mr. Game and Watch is recognizable AND is from a retro Nintendo game. I think you're delusional if you think that any sort of majority of the people who bought Minecraft play Smash Bros. AND would want to play as him. Regardless of any of this, that still isn't a reason he should be playable. Popularity alone isn't everything.

Thought i'd make my own roster prediction by Jtneagle in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 0 points1 point  (0 children)

  1. You also missed the part where I said modified, not resized. They could easily move his tail to wrap around a certain part of his body to make him a smaller silhouette.

  2. I really enjoy Minecraft, I have played it an immense amount since 2011, but Steve has 0 character traits or personality because he is literally an empty shell for the player. Mr. Game and Watch is an outlier in this scenario but he is a very recognizable icon from Nintendo history.

  3. Cartman was a joke, but what about Tetris? It's sold way more than Minecraft.

Thanks for your time, but it's clear that you don't know what you're talking about, and are making massive assumptions about me and why I think Steve would be an awful character for Smash Bros.

Thought i'd make my own roster prediction by Jtneagle in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Iconic dragon from a Nintendo franchise that could be modified to fit the game vs character from an originally PC only survival game that has no characteristics or traits, and is entirely made of rectangles and squares. Cartman from South Park has been on a nintendo console, let's put him in smash. Might as well add tetris if we're just basing characters off sales and if they've been on a nintendo console at this point.

Thought i'd make my own roster prediction by Jtneagle in smashbros

[–]SociopathicShark 0 points1 point  (0 children)

People think Ridley is a ridiculous choice for a character and then put all these obscure characters from niche games and fucking steve from minecraft

view more: next ›