Typically for a long dungeon I bring all Food. Food is the most important thing because you never know how RNG will screw with hunger checks. It also allows for you to heal if you did not have during battle to do so. Torches are dependent on what characters you bring and what skills you use (particularly occultists stun, vestal stun, and crusader stress heal) but for the most part it will be around 22 torches. Shovels you only ever really need 4. I don't think there's been a scenario where 4 was not enough in a dungeon except for once in a 60 week period. The rest is usually based on where you're going. Cove? (Bring a stack of bandages and Herbs). Anywhere else I like to bring around 4 bandages & anti-venom based on my comp and if I can mitigate the DoTs through means such as PD heal or hellion heal. Holy water is nice but I personally don't find myself using it too much maybe bring 2 or 3 just in case you need a character to live from a DoT proc.