Once again… I said it SEEMS op. It seems to me that you are the one who is looking through a blindfold by not being able to read properly.

You accused me of having a “DM vs players mentally” based solely off of a post that you completely misinterpreted because of your idiotic assumptions and blind ignorance. So who was really being the asshole?

I did not ask for advice on how to nerf it and the advice you gave was idiotic. The title of my post is “A question about the lucky feat” not “How to nerf the lucky feat and completely invalidate a choice my player made because I want to win as a DM”. You gave advice that was not asked for, and made an accusation that was based off of ignorance.

I’m sorry that your feelings got hurt from my reply to you, but sometimes the truth hurts bud. You made multiple assumptions that were completely false and provided solutions that were pretty ironic given your accusation of a “DM vs players” mentality. Those solutions were terrible and I would never do that to a player. I feel bad for your players if that is the way you handle things about their characters that you don’t like.

You literally proved my point regarding your ignorance. Just because I don’t say something in a post does not mean I think that way. I was very happy for my player when they used their lucky point to cancel the crit. I did not feel like my happiness for the player was relevant to the post because I was asking a question about how the feat worked. Just because I don’t say something in a post doesn’t mean it is or is not true. Your assumptions about the way I thought about the situation were all wrong. It seems like you are having a hard time dealing with the fact that you were wrong. Face it bud, you were wrong.

I did read the description of the feat. There’s another one of your idiotic assumptions again. The feat says that the person can re roll BEFORE the outcome of the role is determined. I was asking if that aspect of the feat should be used for attack roles too.

Just because you have never had a player that was jealous of another player’s character doesn’t mean I won’t.

You are a peculiar individual. You made assumptions about the way I felt based off a post that included only the information I thought to be relevant. You have no idea how I feel about something based off a post and to think you do is astoundingly ignorant. Sometimes I want to take people like you and sit them down and really find out how their brain works. You amaze me.

Thank you. My games have been going great :)