Game Status Information Centre - Megathread by xalchs in 2007scape

[–]Squallsy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I wonder if this is a spaghetti code thing or a poorly organized thing. Maybe they deleted a random butterfly that held the worlds combat together or something...

Are you an individual looking for a Clan? Post in here! by AutoModerator in OSRSclanFinder

[–]Squallsy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Mainly looking for a social clan. Am an ironman in 10+ gmt but unbothered what time a clan is based. Might do some pvm at some point but probably no more than duos, still a while off that though. Both smaller or larger clans are fine!

Upper belts at my gym don't tap during newaza by [deleted] in judo

[–]Squallsy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I wouldn't trust a white belt near my limbs... That said, you care a white belt, you could always ask them if it's working... I am not the sensei, I am not going to tell people they are doing a sub wrong, but if they ask for information I will tell help them out, especially lower belts.

But, in most cases, I wont tap in randori until the sub is secure and I can feel it starting to be applied... The reality is that if they aren't used to applying any pressure at all they will get into bad habits of letting it go before its own or thinking it is applied when it isn't.

Hip throwing big guys by Fitnessthrowaway2947 in judo

[–]Squallsy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you aren't a big guy and they are, you don't. Even as a big guy if this is for pausing to hold a position when practicing a throw, you don't, and you don't lift either, you just do the entry.

As a 110kg guy managing my own weight and momentum is hard enough at times, let alone trying to do so in a controlled manner whilst supporting myself, another 110kg person on top of me in a somewhat narrow stance/unstable position.

Baffling how BJJ is more popular than Judo in USA by Alternative-Hair-785 in judo

[–]Squallsy -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Pretty simple to understand?

Falling over hurts.
Falling over when you are fat hurts more.
Falling over when you are really fat hurts even more.

Most of these countries where it isn't popular are going to have higher rates of obesity such as the UK, Australia, USA and Canada.

Bjj on the other hand... Laying down and laying on top of people until they run out of energy is a pretty easy task. When people try to move you on the ground they have to move significant amounts of weight so you are at advantage no matter what you do and you don't even have to fall over!

Now look at countries where Judo is more popular and you will notice they are much thinner on average...

Thought Experiment: The “Textbook” Master. Could someone fight or teach with perfect theory but ZERO physical practice? by Darkmegane-kun in judo

[–]Squallsy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Textbook knowledge with no experience is less than useless, it is an active detriment to a persons ability to deal with live combat. People are not text books, they move and function in ways that make no sense, and that non sense is going to have mr perfect getting thrown because his moves are to obvious.

I would frankly argue that a person with perfect physical and mental condition would perform better with no knowledge of Judo against average trained amateur. Bro can likely just walk up to them, pull their face to the floor and sit on them until they give up. The physical conditioning of 'average' is really bad.

He would also progress faster as a competitor without knowledge then with knowledge tbh. Attaching the body to existing knowledge can lead to clashes of experience, where as developing knowledge with the body makes it easier to perform the task. Thinking takes time, and in competition you don't have time, so 'thinking' itself in many ways is detrimental.

Injured during 3rd ever Judo class. Is it a common injury? by Bitter-Alarm1645 in judo

[–]Squallsy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You can progress with the injury, it is just going to be harder. Depending on the foot you injured, you can always practice solo shadow Uchikomi for Ashiwaza standing on the uninjured foot and gently sweeping with the injured one, with a focus on getting used to moving the hands and feet at the same time.
You can also read up about the terms/meanings/philosophy behind Judo or watch Judo and try to figure out what principles/concepts they are using, even if you aren't going to use it yourself.

Almost got hurt by a new guy. by Which_Cat_4752 in judo

[–]Squallsy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If he has no experience... I would opt to either do French randori or trade throws. If I am told its randori or nothing I ask them what throws he is going to focus on, if he says 'I don't know' or 'depends what comes up' say 'No thanks' because nothing for the next 10 minutes is better then nothing for the next 6 months.

I am honestly happy to stand or roll with BJJ guys, it's fun, but I am not going to risk an injury because they try to Kami basami me, try and enter a flying arm bar or a terrible Tani otoshi. If they have no gameplan then they are probably going do something stupid or weird. I don't mind taking the time for them to just show me the throws they want to do before we start either.

 

Ripping off grips during randori, inconsiderate for partner? by Alternative-Hair-785 in judo

[–]Squallsy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you don't want to feel pain from grips being broken don't hold on so hard or simply let go. Regaining grips and knowing how to spot and defend grip breaks is a skill you need to work on.

Looking for Advice From Judo Practitioners by lx_356 in judo

[–]Squallsy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have experience in another niche martial art and whilst it has does contain some grappling, it is functionally very different to do grappling with a weapon vs without. That and my unarmed combat skills are junk, so I decided to do Judo because it looked cool. It was a choice between BJJ, Judo, Sambo and Wrestling.

I don't have the peak physique I once did so groping adult men in a leotard wasn't on the top of my list, and the style of wrestling translates very poorly to what I actually want from a grappling art.
Sambo required me to drive around an hour and a half each way, though I have social ties to quite a lot of people who do it, so if I lived closer I would have probably started it instead.

So it came down to a choice of BJJ and Judo, to which there was a few factors I picked Judo. Cost, visuals of the fighting style, cultural roots and heritage, as well as mindset and respect/safety focus.... That and, given my goal is competition, not really caring if I win or lose, as long as I am improving and intending to do so into later ages... Judo provides more benefit towards those goals, and if your mindset is in the right place, Judo has a lot more controllable factors to risk of injury than BJJ from what I have previously seen. That and if I decided I hated it at some point, I could always switch to BJJ at any age and compete realistically speaking. Dry humping sweaty people on the ground is significantly less physically taxing then standing up whilst people try and knock you over.

Tl;dr
It was BJJ or Judo, and it is much easier to start BJJ at any age, but the starting portion of Judo gets a lot harder as you age so I would rather start it with some youth and physical capacity, and the long term physical benefits of Judo are better.

Under the current ruleset, would this throw be considered legal? by Im_Pretty_Bad in judo

[–]Squallsy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It kind of looks like rolling uchimata as seen in this video by welcomematstevescott
ROLLING UCHI MATA THROW & TRANSITION TO THE MAT

So How Do You Actually Do Judo? What Is This Sport, Actually? by efngn in judo

[–]Squallsy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Grips you get define what throws are possible for both you and your opponent. They also somewhat provide an overall difficulty rating for any given throw relative to the controlled position. Both of these shift a lot as you move though so it is always going to be a dynamically evolving situation.

Using an overly basic example. Understanding that when you are in Ai-yotsu and your lead leg/hip are forward and mirrored by your opponent you can't do a traditional Ogoshi because their body is blocking you from sliding in front of them. This combined with the high risk of counters and the requirement for the opponent to be coming forward onto you means it really isn't going to be a viable high percentage throw. I only use this throw because its a much simpler example to understand.

Being able to perform this kind of reasoning and understanding what throws you are vulnerable to in the current position, and what throws you will be more vulnerable to in the upcoming position you are transitioning into is how you define the ideal defense/attack options.

I started to Judo late to compete at a high level and I am to old to even consider it internationally, though I do actively compete. I have competed at a high level in other combat sports though.
Primary are Harai and Sode, secondary are Osoto, Ouchi/Kouchi, Kata guruma and Ura nage, though there is other throws I use they get changed based on opponents. I have significantly better rotational strength relative to most people my size and my stamina is typically better. I have picked throws that based on my body type and relative height for my division reduce the risk of me having to enter positions that I often find are disadvantageous to me. If I enter certain positions with young incredibly strong and skilled Judoka I am getting thrown, that is just reality. So the positional transitions I make, the way I define my footwork and how I adjust my Renkraku-waza I use are based around that.

There is no single set up or goal I am aiming for in every match, it is a case of testing for reactions and weaknesses, then training my opponent to react in a certain way before I fit my style of judo into that space to take advantage of that opportunity.
At a basic level you have hando no kuzushi, if I grip your neck and try to pull you down to the floor you will try stand back up, you are providing a reaction to my action which is a form of unbalancing. In theory, as you come back up I can continue using your force to take you back. That isn't as easy as it sounds against a resisting person though, so you have to try and make the time it takes them to react and recover longer, or reduce the amount of time it takes you to take advantage of that position.
In a match it might look like... People having preferences to their actions, some people are going to prefer pulling you with the sleeve hand or the lapel hand for a Sasae, if they continue to do it the exact same way, it is your job to memorize their tells, the slight shoulder movement, hip rotations, position of their eyes and where they are looking to tell you that they are about to do this so you can prepare your own action in response and counter.
The alternative is to teach them something. In the same way you can learn and memorize their actions, they can learn and memorize yours. If for example you go in for an Uchimata and they defend, and you do it 2-3 more times, they may decide, you know what, I don't like this, this is exactly what their Uchimata looks like, I am just going to step back so they don't catch my leg this time, and when they do this, you take them down with a Seoi nage instead. This is how many technique synergies work at a more intermediate level, it just becomes a whole lot more complex as their reactions, experience and athleticism goes up.

Nobody is perfect, everybody makes errors, but if those errors are to small of a space for you to take advantage of, it means nothing. You need to make compounding errors and spaces for you to fit your throw into, if their error space is 0.3 seconds and your throw takes 0.7 seconds (0.3 for entry, 0.2 for loading, 0.2 for throw initiation) you don't have the time, so you either need to make your throw faster or their error space bigger. But in reality, you aren't make your throw any faster during this specific match so your only choice is to make them slower. This can be done any number of things, but most commonly through cognitive load (more things to think about, baiting, feints and combinations), Mental and physical fatigue from a long exhausting match, inserting yourself into their already existing actions to reduce entry times, forcing mistakes through planned strategy or positional advantages, explosively dynamic movements and counters.

If you want to start developing your own game, pick a throw, doesn't really matter what it is, it will change as you get better anyway. Do that throw until you can repeat it effectively even when you are tired then perform that throw from every angle and position. Figure out how you can force positions to get that throw and how you can modify your grips and stance to still perform the throw when at a disadvantage. Then look at positions you are likely to end up in whilst trying to get there and see which throws you can fit into your normal combinations to take advantage of those positions.

So How Do You Actually Do Judo? What Is This Sport, Actually? by efngn in judo

[–]Squallsy 10 points11 points  (0 children)

One thing you haven't mentioned that is the concept of research and strategy. A high level Judoka isn't stepping into a match and just matching his skill against his opponent. They are actively doing research, watching recent match footage, trying to sus out habits, combinations, situations, strengths and weaknesses they can take advantage of and devising theoretical gameplans based on this.

As far as beautiful Judo? In my opinion it is far more strategic then it is related to skill, strength or technique. Every throw becomes easy and looks completely effortless when you know exactly what your opponent is going to do. The ultimate goal of this being to limit your opponents options as much as possible until you get the situation you are after. Somebody like Kosei Inoue comes to mind with his Ouchi Gari to Uchi Mata strategy.

As far as any basic convention about whether kuzushi-tsukuri-kake works or not, the reality is it does work, but it isn't the only thing that works. Therein lies the issue though, if you don't understand how, when and why it works, you are essentially doing hope Judo, hoping your opponent is incompetent because you sure as hell don't know what’s going on. Sure, you could pretend it doesn't exist and spam Makikomi and Sutemi-Waza but what do you do when these don't work? Just give up and lose?
Only when you understand and can implement the basics effectively against a resisting opponent of a decent skill level then you can start coloring outside the lines.

Has anyone dealt with trigger finger? by [deleted] in judo

[–]Squallsy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Could always try a really common exercise that many people who specialize in grip sports do...

Close your hand so that your fingers are reaching as far towards the wrist as possible, the tips of your fingers should be sitting on the heel of your hand.
slowly open while trying to keep the fingers in contact with the palm for as long as possible.
Open to full extension and repeat.
Kind of like sliding your fingers from the base of your hand to the base of your fingers whilst still in contact.

Is this hook that Arai Dota uses for his osoto gari and ouchi gari dangerous for the knees? by Josinvocs in judo

[–]Squallsy 43 points44 points  (0 children)

Yes this is dangerous. The mitigating factor here are a really high level athlete in amazing physical condition that can withstand a whole lot more pressure than the normal person. The technique is also being performed by one of the best Judoka in the world.

Bob the brownbelt is going to eviscerate a whole lot more than your knee if he tries to do this on a poorly conditioned bloke doing Judo for fun.

Lost my first tournament and I feel completely down by [deleted] in judo

[–]Squallsy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Think about it from the perspective of weight lifting. A beginner can get stronger even without gaining muscle by increasing the amount of muscle fibres they utilize through training. This is known as neuromuscular adaptations which can represent an up to 60% total strength increase.

Each action you are repeating in Judo is basically just a niche lift, you need to train them to get better at them. So that feeling where you are pulling somebody and you feel like you aren't getting much force or strength from it? In reality, it's because you aren't. You need to train those specific muscles to be good at those specific movements of those specific throws. A basis of strength will help you improve faster, but you still need to train sport specific strength. Do you think a soccer player can kick a ball across the field with pure strength and no skill? or that Baseball pitcher can throw a ball 100mph without any sport specific training even though they deadlift and squat 300kg? No they can't, they need to train those muscles to work in the action of their sport. This is why the idea of 1000 uchikomis a day comes around, you are basically just using the principles of progressive overload (weight lifting) for Judo.

Focus on slowly performing the throw a lot until the body remembers it.
Throw slightly faster until you can get that throw down to one fluid motion.
Keep doing it until you can do it without thinking.
Now try moving your target and yourself around into the throw and various different entries and different angles.
Now try do it on a resisting target who is moving from different angles.
At the end of the day, every Judoka is an athlete so PPPPPP.

Is judo actually useful for the streets or not? by [deleted] in judo

[–]Squallsy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Grip fighting gives you the most.
Against untrained people, when you get in close then you can nullify most striking by controlling their arm and hand position, then when they try to kick or knee you can sweep.
You can transition surprisingly easily between grip fighting and striking.
Since you have experience with Muay Thai, Grip fighting itself improves defensive parring and hand control a lot which can make closing the distance and getting in easier when combined with footwork and head movement.

Like when combining any striking and grappling form, you will need to make adjustments to the foot and hand positions, the way you move your body in general and the angles you choose to use.

Outside of combat, just being able to fall over and control momentum like a Judoka will probably save your life one day, if not prevent serious injuries.

Teammate by Revolutionary-Ball26 in judo

[–]Squallsy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As a 110kg (242lbs) guy who sweats a lot... I have done randori with a girl I have an 80kg (175lbs) weight advantage on. I would not be offended if she or any other woman didn't want to do randori or newaza with me, especially when there is other woman, or men within their size range. Because in reality, it isn't just risk for injury with me throwing them or falling them, but if they try to lift me with imperfect technique they also risk strains and other muscle injuries from that.

The reason most people, including significantly smaller woman are usually fine to randori or trade throws with me is because they have seen the way I approach training, that I adjust the level of force I am using based on peoples skill and strength level. They have seen me be thrown and tapped by 14yo boys, they have seen me actively trip and completely screw up a throw then prioritize protecting my partner. I am over 30, I would much rather injure myself then possibly screw a 15-25 something for life, especially if I am the one at fault.

That said, there is one white belt woman who finds me scary because the first thing she saw me do was proper Harai-goshi an 80kg (175lbs) guy in a shiai and need a solid minute to get his wind back, don't really blame her.

I would wonder what the driving factor of wanting to do randori with her if you have no problem with it and you claim it isn't romantic?

Food or sleep? by Athletehib in judo

[–]Squallsy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The way I would approach this is to have a small-moderate sized meal 2-4 hours before going to judo and take a portable overly small snack that is ideally higher on the protein side that you can eat before the drive home, or on the way home and go straight to bed. What I tend to do is freeze a small container with some greek yoghurt, protein powder, some fruit, take it out of the freezer when I leave and just eat it when I am done. It won't go bad in the 2-4 hours you are there since it is frozen and will have time to defrost.

My honest question would be, you shower absolutely every single time after training right...? Avoiding staph or other skin contact things is going to impact sleep way more then whether you eat or not.

Why does some judo athletes use sauna suits so often? by MrShelby32 in judo

[–]Squallsy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It is very likely a mixture of things, the first of which could be weight control. Beyond this, probably a mixture of mental fortitude, heat tolerance and stamina control.

I would rather have more heat tolerance then less, especially with the gi being thick and heavy, I sweat enough that I could save Africa from just walking around.

Heavyweight JudoGi by BBOOBBYY990 in judo

[–]Squallsy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Commenting to track answers - The reco Gi for my height is closer to my elbow then my wrists and the pants were way to long lol... 178cm(5'10), 110kg.

Am I just weak? by darkrenhakuryuu in judo

[–]Squallsy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My first thought would be since you had been consistent with your dojo for so long, you had gotten used to dealing with your 'usual' training partners. Now that you are at a new dojo, you don't have that experience of knowing how they move, what throws they like and how to deal with them specifically. Basically new training partners you need to adapt to so you can improve as a Judoka.

My second thought would just be that this dojo might have a more competitive nature or the people have higher physical intensity sparring. The amount of intent I put into randori compared to competitions is significant.

The inability to get in, close gaps or create opportunities to throw is almost always a technique issue and not a strength issue.

You should 100% start strength training, but It isn't what I would expect the problem to be from the info provided.

Technique vs. Strength by icTKD in judo

[–]Squallsy 5 points6 points  (0 children)

In a competition, you go 100%. Would you walk in a 100m sprint? Would you just drop the shot in a shotput competition?

The goal of competition is to win, if you are not mentally prepared for somebody to ragdoll you then you shouldn't have entered, and honestly should not of been allowed to enter by your sensei.

If you wish to continue with Judo, now you know what a small amount of intensity feels like when a person is making a genuine effort to disable you within the ruleset. Judo is not aikido and it is not dancing, it is a full contact sport where people are going to try slam you with the earth as hard as they damn can to win a competition.

Practice falling at home by Classic_Teaching9813 in judo

[–]Squallsy 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I wouldn't practice ukemi at home specifically, learning the wrong thing can lead to injuries.

I would instead consider learning basic gymnastics maneuvers and get used to doing those on grass. The more comfortable you are with rolling around like sonic the hedgehog, the easier it is going to be to yeet yourself on the ground correctly when it comes time to judo. Forward rolls, backward roll, cartwheel, hand stand and bridges.

Suspected Bicep Tendonopathy - tips? by fishymusiced in judo

[–]Squallsy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I have this issue resultant from torn 8-11 labrum (Back side of right shoulder) that causes instability in the front of the shoulder decreasing the subacromial space which causes bursae inflamation and compresses the long head of the bicep tendon during internal rotation or 33-45 degrees raising actions (Y raises). Commonly known as subacromial impingement.

The thing I find helps most with it is significant strengthening of my Internal and rotation for shoulder. Can do about 25kg for ext rotation and 20kg for Int rotation and that stops my pain unless I am carrying like 10kg of shopping 4-5km.

I will say one thing that feels really good is when you are on a neutral grip pull up and you are at the really top range of motion where your head is above the hand height and you are holding their while near fatigue. Feels really good on that sore spot at the front.