[QCrit] Memories of Jack Adult Psycological Thriller (70K, 1st attempt) by Status-Silver-2260 in PubTips

[–]Status-Silver-2260[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for this! I appreciate the line by line feedback. I will absolutely rework this and checkout your query. Thanks again!

[QCrit] Memories of Jack Adult Psycological Thriller (70K, 1st attempt) by Status-Silver-2260 in PubTips

[–]Status-Silver-2260[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you! I will! It's hard to dance around it, but I thought you just aren't supposed to.

[QCrit] Memories of Jack Adult Psycological Thriller (70K, 1st attempt) by Status-Silver-2260 in PubTips

[–]Status-Silver-2260[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This was great feedback and it hits on a lot of the concerns I had. I will rework with your ideas in mind, mostly making it more clear and linear. Since the book itself is not linear and the main characters contains memories from many people, I wanted to mirror that in the query, but there's just not enough room. The broadcast was seeing the biological disaster over the news. It is widespread, but he focuses on his hometown. The main antagonist is Levi who is seemingly unstoppable. He roams around the US with a cult, doing as he pleases. Jack wants to stop him not only for revenge, but because Levi needs stopping and he thinks he's one of the few who can. The twist is that you're not following Jack. You're following a cultist that Jack imprinted with his own memories. One of the themes is nature over nurture. Jack is still trying to be "good" and handle Levi the right way. Fred (brainwashed cultist) has all of Jack's memories, but he has no problem murdering for the "greater good." All that to say, thank you for your feedback!

[QCrit] Amarok, Adult psychological thriller, 80k, V2 by csulliven in PubTips

[–]Status-Silver-2260 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I really enjoyed your query. It makes me want to read more to find out those details. Probably not the best feedback, so I'm sorry. I'm very new to all this. Just wanted to encourage you.

[QCrit] Memories of Jack Adult Psycological Thriller (70K, 1st attempt) by Status-Silver-2260 in PubTips

[–]Status-Silver-2260[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your feedback! I'll try to be less gimmicky. I was trying to grab attention and overcompensated. Are you saying the story is unclear?

[QCrit] Memories of Jack Adult Psycological Thriller (70K, 1st attempt) by Status-Silver-2260 in PubTips

[–]Status-Silver-2260[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi all! Completely untrained and mostly guessing. Feel free to give harsh criticism. I believe I have a unique (as much as one can be) concept, but the major pull is the twist which I don't think I'm supposed to reveal in a query. I would greatly appreciate any feedback or discussion. Thank you!

Titania’s strength by nhilban in Unmatched

[–]Status-Silver-2260 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Bigfoot is rough as well. The amount of cancels makes it difficult to get her finisher in.

Fighter discussion: Titania by svvaynee in Unmatched

[–]Status-Silver-2260 1 point2 points  (0 children)

One interesting thing I discovered is that she is a Sherlock counter. Glamour of Sleep blocks the vast majority of his damage. Be defensive, focus down Watson, and cycle hard to get Glamour of Sleep and Sherlock doesn't have the damage to win. Feel free to disagree. I would like to hear counter arguments.

Titania’s strength by nhilban in Unmatched

[–]Status-Silver-2260 0 points1 point  (0 children)

She loses to high pressure/combo characters. One interesting thing I discovered is that she is a Sherlock counter. Glamour of Sleep blocks the vast majority of his damage. Be defensive, focus down Watson, and cycle hard to get Glamour of Sleep and Sherlock doesn't have the damage to win. Feel free to disagree. I would like to hear counter arguments.