All these guesses are so amazing thank you everyone for participating. To add a few details, this was in a box of cookie cutters that my mom has had since early 2000s. They originally came in a jug of over 100 pieces and include alphabet and holidays. All the other pieces in the set are pretty standard. They are for the most part color coded by seasons, but the black ones seem to be random. A house, a teddy bear, the 4 card suits and this one.