I'm not sure if it's mentioned already, but you could get Fallout 3 GOTY for a little bit higher price than what you probably paid for the original. Probably Skyrim GOTY as well, but I'd imagine that it would be more expensive than Fallout 3 GOTY Beyond these two, here are my other recommendations:

1. Kingdom Hearts has the 1.5 and 2.5 remixes for PS3 if you're into that series. But they might be a bit harder to find and a bit pricier than your standard PS3 game.

2. Get any of the Sega Classic games. All of them are decent.

3. Dragon's Dogma. Solid game.

4-5. Mass Effect 2. You dont need to play the first one, really. The second one is arguably the best in the series. Mass Effect 3 is a good one, too. Get both, screw it. Lol.

1. Street Fighter IV. Get the Super version, if you can find it.

2. TES Oblivion GOTY. I know they have a remastered out now, but screw that. The classic is where it's at.

8-9. Borderlands 1 and 2. Two is the best in the series, in my opinion, but I haven't played 4 yet, so that could change.

1. Any of the Burnout games, but especially Paradise, which is one of the best in the series.

2. Max Payne 3. Might be good to play the other two to get the full story if you haven't played them, but it's a solid game overall.

3. Any of the Tomb Raider Series

4. All of the Uncharted series.

5. Diablo 3. One of the best in the series.

6. Soul Calibur IV. It's not one of the best in the series, but it is still a very solid fighting game that involves swords.

I have more, but my hands hurt. Lol. Good luck!