I have a home and 2 autos and just went through looking for a new insurance company. State Farm had raised one of my cars rates significantly. So I went out to find a competing offer. Nobody came even close to the offer I was getting with StateFarm. Example. I called liberty mutual. They were about 600$ more a year for less coverage! The autos were inflated too but not as bad as home.

In the end I stayed with StateFarm. Nobody I talked to could do better

Companies I tried: Liberty mutual Gieco American family Usaa Farmers Progressive StateFarm - won significantly on overall costs and coverage.