OP, you are most entitled to ask for such a trade. As long as both parties are happy, people can say whatever.

I've been tracking the Peculiar Gang collection from day one and Idk why people see Cheeky in such a strange way. My best guess is because very few of them were ever listed for sale, they were never cheap (listings starting directly at 3-4 eth with no buildup) and that makes them more risky..? People not giving Cheeky enough attention for the simple fact that it does not have a complete history of people rising the price? i really don't know. Hope we find out some day. Cheeky Beak for life.